The Sunday Times of Malta

COULD PARLIAMENT­ARY IMMUNITY ‘SAVE’ JOSEPH MUSCAT?

- JACOB BORG

Joseph Muscat’s possible return to frontline politics has led to accusation­s he is seeking to benefit from European Parliament immunity.

The ex-prime minister’s potential election bid comes amid a moneylaund­ering and corruption probe into his role in the failed Vitals/Steward hospitals’ concession.

Muscat, who denies wrongdoing, opened the door to the prospect of contesting the June European Parliament elections on the Labour ticket.

PN MEP candidate Peter Agius suggested that the ex-prime minister’s real game is to protect himself from prosecutio­n, thanks to the immunity granted to all MEPs.

Labour MEP Alex Agius Saliba has dismissed the immunity argument as

“frivolous”, as MEPs have even had their immunity stripped “over a simple parking ticket”.

So, what are the rules?

Much like Maltese MPs, MEPs benefit from immunity for any opinions and votes taken within parliament. In Malta, this is more commonly known as parliament­ary privilege.

The immunity is meant to prevent MEPs from being impeded or intimidate­d by any type of judicial proceeding­s brought against them because of their parliament­ary work.

Immunity in the European Parliament goes one step further, as its members also benefit from a “personal immunity” that protects them from the threat of arrest or legal proceeding­s during travel and in the course of their parliament­ary work.

This immunity is, however, far from absolute. The European Parliament has the right to waive immunity, and generally does so, unless there are reasons to believe that a prosecutio­n is politicall­y motivated.

Both Muscat and, more recently, Prime Minister Robert Abela have sought to cast doubts on the integrity of the Vitals/Steward inquiry.

If local prosecutor­s were to proceed against Muscat, they would likely put in a request to the European Parliament to waive his immunity.

An MEP also has the right to “defend” his or her immunity in front of the EP legal affairs committee.

Muscat insists that the immunity argument is moot, as a serious investigat­ion will find he has done nothing wrong.

MEPs do sometimes put up a legal fight to protect their immunity.

Eva Kaili, a suspect in the Qatargate bribery scandal which rocked the European Parliament, had sought to derail a separate probe by the European

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Malta