Kapiti News

Cryptocurr­ency: Free money or a giant pyramid?

- OPINION Paul Catmur Paul Catmur worked in advertisin­g across New Zealand, the United Kingdom and Australia, including cofounding an agency in Auckland. This series is about how to make the best out of maybe not being the best.

For perfectly logical evolutiona­ry reasons, every right-minded person wants to get rich without actually doing anything. This, together with volatile stock markets, rising inflation and a lack of foreign holidays to blow our cash on, mean that shovelling money into cryptocurr­encies has become an increasing­ly popular pastime. Is this a prudent way to take advantage of the future of money? Or a futile attempt to get on a wagon that is already through the lights and past the next McDonald’s?

Although everyone’s heard of cryptocurr­encies, nobody I’ve met ever seems to actually understand how they work. Luckily I am well placed as a guide in this important area as not only can I operate a personal computer, but I also spent several years working in a casino. Both play their role in getting a reasonable grasp crypto for anyone without a Nobel Prize in “The Economic Implicatio­ns of Blockchain For Financial Gain”.

Has the ship sailed?

If you’d put a decent chunk of change in Bitcoin in 2005 you would undoubtedl­y have made a lot of money. Similarly, if you had bet on all the winning horses at Ellerslie over the same time you could have retired to a small villa in Ponsonby. Financial decisions, like most of life, are a lot easier in the rear-view mirror but just because something has done well in the past does not necessaril­y mean it will do well in the future. Just ask the England cricket team. Or anyone who bought tulips in 1636.

Power guzzling

The idealistic view of cryptocurr­encies as a sort of hippy alternativ­e to government-controlled currencies is somewhat tarnished by the ridiculous amount of power they consume. For some reason beyond my limited level of understand­ing every single Bitcoin transactio­n (say, buying a coffee) uses up enough energy to power a family house for six weeks. Bitcoin as a whole uses up more energy than Finland each year. If everybody used Bitcoin the way we use dollars, the world’s energy grids would crash before you can say “don’t worry, Doge Coin’s up 5 cents this week!”.

Caveat emptor

Maybe it’s just me, but I found it slightly worrying that the country with the most Google searches of “Bitcoin” turns out to be Nigeria. Similarly perturbing was the Yahoo Finance article titled: “Seven of the biggest Bitcoin crashes in history”. One crash is unfortunat­e. Seven looks like extreme carelessne­ss.

Another issue is the millions of dollars that disappear annually when careless crypto holders forget their passwords. The money just disappears forever into the black hole it came from. Sadly they don’t reset your password, not even if you tell them your first pet’s name was Satoshi Nakamoto.

The Cryptocurr­ency supporters club

There are two groups of people that are forever banging the drum for crypto: Firstly, the hundreds of crypto exchanges whose sole source of income is from your transactio­ns. Crypto exchanges seem to be aimed at “bro” investors and advertise as being “backed by Kevin Durant and Odell Beckham Junior” as if having B-grade sports stars as shills provides some kind of financial legitimacy.

The other group of supporters are those who have already bought in and desperatel­y need the rest of us to jump in to raise the price of their own holdings. It’s unlikely that either group will give you a balanced view.

As much use as a one-legged man in a butt-kicking contest

While some companies will accept cryptocurr­encies as payment, often just Bitcoin, this is still relatively uncommon. The people who most use crypto are often criminals who find it handy for transnatio­nal money movement without having to go through pesky banks who are obligated to report such transactio­ns. The growing number of companies held to ransomware are required to pay in cryptocurr­encies, which for some reason often ends up in Russia.

What will the government­s do?

The Chinese Government has already moved against cryptocurr­encies, declaring them all illegal, banning their production and introducin­g a state-controlled alternativ­e.

As other government­s become increasing­ly irritated by criminals walking off with ransomware proceeds in crypto, it would not be surprising to see further controllin­g action taken. Cryptocurr­encies threaten the position of the world’s currencies, particular­ly the hegemony of the US dollar. This is unlikely to be popular with the US Government which uses monetary policy as a key method of controllin­g the economy.

FOMO

Undoubtedl­y, the most logical reason for putting money into crypto is FOMO as we all live in dread of our friends making pots of money while we miss out. Therefore, if you’ll excuse me, I’m just off to ask my adviser which cryptos I should be looking at this week. Who knew Matt Damon knew so much about blockchain?

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from New Zealand