Text the editor

Parasite tackled

Your recent editorial about the flat oyster parasite Bonamia ostreae questioned if the Ministry for Primary Industries could have moved more swiftly following the detection of the parasite in Big Glory Bay and used a ‘‘more aggressive approach’’ in Marlborough to contain it.

We’re currently working with local farmers to remove all flat oyster stocks from marine farms in both areas.

Since detection of Bonamia ostreae in Big Glory Bay on 24 May, MPI has set up a response team to manage the issue, put in place movement controls, engaged with affected farmers and the local industry and more.

We have established a field headquarters to provide support to Stewart Island farmers and others on the ground.

The actual removal of oysters will start this week.

There is a need for urgency, but also the need to ensure any decisions we make are wellconsidered and have the best possible likelihood of limiting spread.

We needed to undertake a careful process, ensuring the perspectives of all parties were considered thoroughly and fairly. Rushing this process could have potentially disastrous consequences.

In 2015 when the parasite was first detected in Marlborough, we made a decision based on the best available information at the time.

Scientific advice was carefully considered.

Our decision then was that strict controls were sufficient to stop the spread.

Extensive testing shows Bonamia ostreae isn’t in any areas close to Marlborough outside of the controlled area, which indicates these controls have been effective.

The detection of the parasite in Big Glory Bay means the risks are now different, which is why we’re removing oysters in both areas. This reduces the overall presence of Bonamia ostreae nationally, limiting the chance of further spread. (abridged) Ministry for Primary Industries

Geoff Gwyn Support for cycling

As one of the instigators of the Palmerston North bid, some years ago, to host the NZ Cycling Centre of excellence in Palmerston North, I observe with interest the current discussion about whether or not our city should support the initiative to roof the velodrome at Whanganui.

A roofed facility up the road will provide a place where track cyclists from around the region can train and race when the weather is poor, and as a cyclist, I am supportive of that. On the other hand, there are very few track cyclists in the region, and thus relatively few will benefit unless there are significant changes to the facility which will enable other sports to the covered space.

If we do provide Whanganui financial support, I would like to think that they will return the favour, providing similar support for cycling-related infrastructure or events here in Palmerston North. To date, the talk has been very much about what we can do for them.

Steve Stannard

Palmerston North

Staff turnover needed

I think any organisation,whether private, politicall or charitable, to be effective needs a constant turnover off staff. Sitting in comfy office chairs, surrounded by cobwebs, and diet drinks, just doesn’t fit in 2017. Do the right thing. Step down, move on, give someone else a go.

C Sibley

Palmerston North

Meat is healthy

In response to the article titled ‘‘Vegetarian diet keeps fat at bay’’, the single study is on a small group of only 72 type-2 diabetics over a period of six months, therefore does not account for the current body of evidence with regards to eating patterns and health outcomes, nor does this single study constitute overall nutrition recommendations for the New Zealand population.

Regardless of whether one chooses to follow a vegetarian or non-vegetarian eating pattern, both can result in a healthful lifestyle depending on the quality and nutrient composition of one’s ❚ Why did the Manawatu District Council get rid of the log swing at Timona Park? It was the best thing at the playground. Hours of fun for both kids and adults. ❚ Why do we hav beggars? Just another american trend they started. You guys need to go to WINZ, not the public. Sort out ur priorities. I struggle, but I don’t beg. I’ve got some self-esteem. KAM ❚ Wonderful to see many people bringing their own shopping bags to the supermarket! Let’s all help reduce plastic waste. Jacqui ❚ I have been assaulted by beggar’s was shoved when I said no went to police was told I could make a complaint but couldn’t see the point they said they would speak to him. ❚ It has been stated, twice, that trucks are causing the demise of the Gorge. Previously it was the windmills, what next? Could it just be that they patch it up, make no actual upgrades and clear off until it collapses again. ❚ New street lights are dim. People cannot see. Be even worse when leaves back on tree. ❚ By all means, charge the corporate farms for water with their big monstrosity pivots and a thousand cows. But why charge those who’ve taken steps to help the waterways and don’t pollute as much or use irrigation?

diet, and the way one chooses to live. An eating regime that aims to reduce body fat is achievable whether vegetarian or not, and I recommend those needing assistance, to seek the advice of a registered dietitian or nutritionist.

The comments on environmental benefits to having more meat-free days does not take into account how our beef and lamb are raised here in New Zealand. The pastures of which they are raised are only suitable for livestock, would otherwise be wasted and our farmers take great pride in treating the land and its animals to the utmost highest standard, where they take care of the farms they manage and leave in a better condition for the next generations to come.

The NZ meat industry endorses the recommendations by the Ministry of Health and Diabetes NZ with regards to meat consumption, which is that of moderation, not eaten every day, served lean and with plenty of vegetables and wholegrains, and within a healthy lifestyle.

(abridged) Beef + Lamb NZ

Fiona Greig