Turgid supernatural tale misfires
Comedian Gilbert Gottfried has a gag he calls ‘‘my impression of Robert De Niro’s agent’’. Gottfried answers an imaginary phone and immediately screams,’’He’ll Do It!’’, down the mouthpiece. Cue hilarity all round.
It’s funny because we wonder if it’s close to the truth. After seeing Winchester, I’m also thinking maybe Helen Mirren is represented by the same guy.
Winchester is based – very loosely – on a few weeks in the life of Sarah Winchester, as played by Mirren. Winchester inherited an absolute shedload of money and shares in the family firearms company when her husband died aged only 43.
The Winchester fortune was built on the famous repeating rifle, as seen in every Western ever made. And that was a source of much angst to the widowed Sarah. Some writers claim Sarah believed she was haunted and cursed by the spirits of everyone the family’s gun had killed.
In this telling, Sarah’s decision to endlessly build and rebuild her vast wooden mansion in San Jose, California is a symptom of her ghost-induced madness.
It’s a good yarn, and in the hands of a smart writer and inventive director it could have yielded a terrific, blackly comic film. But sadly all the smart writers and inventive directors were stuck in traffic on the day Winchester was put together – leaving the Spierig Brothers ( Jigsaw) to turn in this turgid and dispiriting load of old wallop.
The script is an episodic and disjointed mess that never generates any tension or dread, so the only scares are of the very fleeting something-jumps-out-ofthe-shadows kind. We’ve seen it all done before, better and far more inventively. 2016’s Annabelle: Creation was no great horror movie, but it had a few moments that make even the best of Winchester look about as menacing as an episode of Scooby Doo.
It also seems to me any film about a widow driven to madness by the ghosts of the victims of her family’s guns had at least the potential to work in a dark satire of the whole arms business.
Winchester flails in that direction in a few scenes, but soon just lurches back to being a disappointing, resolutely un-scary and unforgivably boring slog.
The house, which should be a star of the show and practically a character in its own right, is reduced to a handful of stock shots – all obviously filmed on the same sunny day, while the interiors never look like anything other than a series of flimsy sets on a soundstage, miles away from the action. There is simply no connection between the exterior and the interior. Which will serve well enough as a description of the entire film. Although Winchester has a few attractive surfaces, it never once engages the heart or the brain.
Mirren and Jason Clarke – as a doctor tasked with assessing Sarah’s sanity – are fine, of course. But neither of them ever convince us they are genuinely scared of whatever is about to happen.
I couldn’t shake the feeling there must be a hell of a lot of outtakes of the pair of them collapsing into helpless giggles at the nonsense they’re being paid to spout. The Exorcist this ain’t.
– Graeme Tuckett Nicole Kidman, James Franco and Damian Lewis star in Werner Herzog’s 2015 chronicle of Gertrude Bell’s life. She was a traveller, writer, archaeologist, explorer, cartographer, and political attache´ for the British Empire at the dawn of the 20th century. ‘‘It is grown-up, respectable and historical, perfectly competently made, lots of accents and period dressing-up … and just the tiniest bit dull,’’ wrote The Guardian‘ s Peter Bradshaw.
Rolling Stone: Stories From the Edge, 9.35pm, Tuesday, Prime
Narrated by Jeff Daniels, this twopart, 2017 documentary chronicles the last 50 years of American The Prime Minister’s significant other, Clarke Gayford, returns with another series devoted to travelling to some of the world’s most idyllic fishing spots. In this week’s first episode, he’s off to Vanuatu to track down a fish that once almost drowned him – a Dog Tooth Tuna.
Who Do You Think You Are? 8.30pm, Wednesday, BBC Knowledge
Season 14 of this inspiring and informative BBC genealogy series This 2016 documentary sees Kirsten Johnson reaching into the vast trove of footage she has shot over decades around the world. ‘‘It all could have easily become a cacophony of disconnected sights and sounds, but Cameraperson unfolds with beauty and purpose — mixing the fluidity of a dream with the acuity of an essay,’’ wrote Village Voice‘ s Bilge Ebiri.