Time for an ecocide law
change, while closing their eyes to the far greater toll that is being paid for failing to act. Australian MP Craig Kelly appeared on British television this week and continued to deny the link between climate change and the Australian bushfires.
Now is the time to change that.
The late British barrister Polly Higgins led a decade-long campaign to make ecocide a crime. In a submission to the United Nations Law
Commission in 2010, she explained ecocide as being ‘‘the loss, damage or destruction of ecosystem(s) of a given territory . . . such that peaceful enjoyment by the inhabitants has been or will be severely diminished.’’
Ecocide covers the direct damage done to sea, land, flora and fauna, as well as the cascading impact on the world’s climate. The term was first used in the 1970s at the Conference on War and National Responsibility in Washington, and academics and lawyers have in the decades since then argued for the criminalisation of ecocide.
Ecocide would sit alongside the four other international crimes – genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and crimes of aggression – which are set out in the 1998 Rome Statute that established the International Criminal Court.
Higgins’ website, www. ecocidelaw.com, explains that there is currently no international, legally binding duty of care towards the Earth. This means that companies can destroy environments and communities for profit without fear of prosecution.
The website states that existing laws put shareholders first, meaning that the laws of individual nations are regularly contravened in the pursuit of financial returns – often with the consent of governments that issue permits to pollute.
Higgins’ vision was that a crime of ecocide would act as both a brake on companies by making senior executives personally criminally responsible, and discourage government ministers from facilitating harmful activity and make banks and investors less likely to finance it. Like senior executives, ministers would face the prospect of criminal proceedings.
Ecological Defence Integrity was founded by Higgins and Jojo Mehta in June 2017 to lobby for the creation of a crime of ecocide under the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court. It launched the public campaign Stop Ecocide in November 2017.
Four elements would comprise the crime of ecocide:
A perpetrator’s acts or omissions causing ecocide
The actions severely diminishing peace
The perpetrator having knowledge of actual or possible outcomes; and
The perpetrator being a senior official.
Ecocide law would also provide legal backing to the campaigns of indigenous communities in many nations to protect their lands.
Ecocide is already recognised as a crime in 10 nations, including the Russian Federation, Ukraine, Vietnam and Belarus.
Scientists have warned humans about climate change for decades, and we have ignored those warnings. Only last month, Australia and the United States worked with other nations at COP25 to block stronger action on climate change.
A crime of ecocide would prohibit harmful activity and force governments, businesses and financiers to prioritise clean generation and production.
New Zealand is included in that imperative. We are watching on in horror at the Australian bushfires, but our own action to combat climate change is woefully inadequate.
Cat Maclennan is a barrister and founder of Animal Agenda Aotearoa.