Sentences for drugs criticised
Hundreds of people are locked up for petty drug offences every year – many for crimes our top legal body says should not exist.
Justice Ministry figures show a significant amount of court time is taken up by minor drug cases, with nearly as many people imprisoned for possessing a small quantity of cannabis as for dealing.
Among these offenders are hundreds imprisoned for possessing a pipe or a needle, an offence the Law Commission recommended removing from the statutes last year.
The figures also show that less than one in three minor drug offenders is offered diversion, allowing them to avoid a criminal record.
The New Zealand Drug Foundation said the figures were alarming and showed the court-focused treatment of minor offenders was not working.
But Justice Minister Judith Collins said all drug offending – no matter how minor – should be dealt with through the criminal justice system.
In the past six years, possession of small amounts of cannabis or smoking utensils, such as a pipe, made up about a half of all drug charges laid by police.
While most offenders received a fine or community work, more than 2800 were imprisoned for minor drug offences.
These included possession of needles, pipes, and small amounts of cannabis or methamphetamine.
Imprisonment for petty offences almost equals the number locked up for more serious crimes.
Drug Foundation executive director Ross Bell said locking up minor drug offenders was simply stupid policy.
‘‘You send someone away for a minor drug conviction and they can come out a meth cook,’’ he said.
Rather than dealing with people through the criminal justice system, the Government could introduce a mandatory cautioning scheme, he said.
‘‘For a drug like cannabis you could get three cautions before being diverted to a treatment programme. We are not talking about decriminalising or legalising, it’s about a more pragmatic way to get help for people who need it.’’
However, Ms Collins said the justice system was the right place for all drug offenders.
‘‘The Government relies on enforcement agencies such as police to make appropriate decisions on how to charge someone for their offending, and the judiciary to make appropriate sentencing decisions based on the circumstances of individual cases.’’
The Government had policies to ensure anyone requiring treatment for drug abuse received it, she said.
Last year a Law Commission’s review of New Zealand’s 35-year-old drug laws criticised the uneven and criminally focused approach to drug offending.
It also recommended a three strike system for minor offending, and legalising pipes and needles.
Police opposed most recommendations and the Government has only followed up on a handful of recommendations, notably introducing drug courts.
However, the figures show the police may have started to pursue minor drug offenders less aggressively. In the year to June 2012, there was a substantial drop in the number of people being charged, convicted and imprisoned for possession of drugs or utensils.
Police said the drop could be attributed to the introduction of precharge warnings in September 2010.
The move gave police discretion to warn rather than charge people arrested on offences carrying a sentence of six months or less imprisonment. Police say people charged with drug possession are likely to get diversion, particularly on a first offence, but ministry figures show minor drug charges usually result in a conviction. Carterton, 300 people crammed into a church near the scene to remember their loved ones. Bob Hopkirk, whose son Stephen died in the tragedy on January 7 last year, spoke outside the service at St Mark’s Church in Carterton yesterday morning, saying the past year had been ‘‘up and down’’. Another six months’ wait until the release of findings into the causes of the crash was ‘‘not going to make much difference’’, he said. During the service, family, friends and accident witnesses lit candles and said the name of their loved ones.