India’s cow problem
Stray cows are adding to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s farmer woes as the Indian election looms, report Rajendra Jadhav and Mayank Bhardwaj , of Reuters.
WHILE stray cows ambling around towns and villages have always been a feature of life in rural India, farmers say their number has increased sharply in recent years to the extent they have become a menace, and they blame the policies of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist government.
AS night fell on the bucolic northern Indian hamlet of Mahaban, Gopi Chand Yadav gathered blankets and a flashlight to spend the night sitting on a wooden platform in his field. His task: to use bamboo sticks to ward off stray cattle from intruding and eating a maturing mustard crop.
Like Yadav, many thousands of farmers stay awake to guard their farms over a cold winter or face losing their crops to the cattle — a double whammy for growers already reeling from a plunge in Indian crop prices.
While stray cows ambling around towns and villages have always been a feature of life in rural India, farmers say their number has increased sharply in recent years to the extent they have become a menace, and blame the policies of
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist government.
Protecting cows — considered sacred to Hindus — was one of the measures meant to shore up support in the heavily populated, Hindispeaking belt across northern India that has been a heartland of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP).
Instead, it is creating a backlash, even among Hindu farmers.
‘‘We already had enough problems and now the Government has created one more,’’ said octogenarian farmer Baburao Saini from Kakripur village, about 85km from New Delhi.
‘‘For the first time, we’ve been forced to stay in the fields to protect our crops.’’
More than 50 farmers Reuters spoke to in Mahaban and nine other villages in Uttar Pradesh state said they would think twice before voting for Modi’s BJP in the next general election, due by May. The cattle issue and low farm prices are major reasons behind their disillusionment with a party that most say they voted for in the last election in 2014.
Modi swept Uttar Pradesh at that poll, winning 73 of 80 seats in India’s most populous state, with rural voters swayed by a promise of higher crop prices, and as Hindu farmers supported the BJP amid tensions with the minority Muslim community.
Cow protection
Modi is trying hard to claw back support among India’s 263 million farmers and their many millions of dependants after the BJP lost power in December to the opposition Congress in three big northern states where agriculture is a mainstay.
Indian farmers keep cows to produce milk, cheese and butter, but to harm or kill a cow, especially for food, is considered taboo by most Hindus.
Most states in India have long outlawed cow slaughter, but after coming to power in 2014 the BJP ratcheted up its distaste for trade in cattle, launching a crackdown on unlicensed abattoirs in Uttar Pradesh and on cattle smuggling nationwide.
At the same time, a wave of attacks on trucks carrying cattle by Hindu vigilante groups has scared away traders, most of whom are Muslims, bringing to a halt the trade even in bullocks, which are not considered sacred. Rising sales of tractors and increasing mechanisation mean more animals are redundant for use in farming.
The farmers Reuters spoke to said they revered cows as most devout Hindus would, but a sudden halt in the trade of cattle had hit the rural economy. In their view, the Government should come up with more cow shelters and let cattle traders deal in other animals without fear of attack.
‘‘The Government has only enforced the laws by closing down unlicensed abattoirs and cracking down on cattle smuggling,’’ said BJP spokesman Gopal Krishna Agarwal, who added that he runs a cow shelter of 1300 cattle.
‘‘We’re not trying to hurt either any community or the rural economy.’’
Crop trampled
Fodder prices had gone up by more than a third in the past year and most farmers could not afford to keep cows after they stopped producing milk, farmer Rajesh Pahalwan said in the village of Manoharpur. Six farmers sitting with him mainly nodded in agreement.
In India, the world’s biggest milk producer, about 3 million cattle become unproductive every year. In the past, Hindu farmers would sell unproductive cows to Muslim traders and about 2 million of these would end up smuggled to Bangladesh for meat and leather. But that trade has now been throttled by the government crackdown, trade and industry officials say.
That had led to many unproductive cattle being abandoned, farmers said, but governments — both state and federal — had failed to construct new shelters, leaving rising numbers of stray cattle feeding on crops, or even garbage.
‘‘The Government clearly did not think of alternatives before putting these curbs in place,’’ said farmer Deepak Chaudhary, who grows wheat on the outskirts of Mathura, considered to be the birthplace of the Hindu God Krishna.
‘‘As Hindus, we treat cows as sacred but these unwarranted measures have upended the economics of farming.’’
The Government did provide some relief in its recent interim budget as it announced a cow welfare programme costing 7.50 billion rupees ($NZ152.7 million) in the year beginning April.
But there were hardly any ‘‘adequate measures to rehabilitate’’ cattle, Fauzan Alvi, vicepresident of the All India Meat and Livestock Exporters Association, said.
‘‘Forget about cows; we cannot sell even a single animal to even our relatives thanks to cow vigilante groups which are aided and abetted by the BJP,’’ the wheat farmer Chaudhary said.
Modi has in the past condemned violence by cow vigilantes, but critics and opposition politicians say some of the rightwing Hindu groups involved have links to his party, a charge the BJP denies.
Nearly 85% of India’s farmers own less than 2ha of land, so even a relatively small area damaged by wandering cows has a big impact on their livelihood.
Only two weeks ago, some cattle ravaged 0.5ha of wheat grown by farmer Chandra Pal in the Mathura district of Uttar Pradesh.
‘‘My investment went down the drain after some stray cattle trampled and ate up the crop,’’ he said.
Many farmers in Uttar Pradesh are now using barbed wire to stop animals from entering their farms, but that is expensive.
‘‘We have been at the receiving end of antifarmer policies of the Government and the problem of stray cattle is just another blow to us,’’ said farmer Amar Chand, of Maholi village who voted for Modi in 2014.
‘‘Unlike the previous general election, farmers are not solidly behind Modi, who’s on shaky ground this time round.’’
We have been at the receiving end of antifarmer policies of the Government and the problem of stray cattle is just another
blow to us