Scepticism mixed with humour in address
A DUNEDIN audience was treated to a healthy dose of scepticism yesterday.
Bestselling US science writer Dr Michael Shermer blended almost equal portions of humour and scepticism into a lively closing address at a Dunedin conference on ‘‘Science and the Afterlife’’.
The twoday ScienceTeller event was codirected by University of Otago Associate Prof
Jesse Bering and Prof Jamin Halberstadt, of the Otago psychology department.
After Dr Shermer (64) had taken a robustly sceptical view of the afterlife, Prof Bering, who directs the Otago Science Communication Centre, asked him what wording he would like to see on his own gravestone.
‘‘I’ll be back!’’ Dr Shermer replied with a smile.
His other suggestion was about someone who ‘‘wanted to know’’ what was true. His talk, to more than 70 people at the university College of Education Auditorium, was titled ‘‘Michael Shermer’s Scientific Search for the Afterlife, Immortality and Utopia’’.
Of persistent attempts to freeze human bodies for potential later longterm reanimation, Dr Shermer said ‘‘I’m not recommending it — it doesn’t work’’.
A currently more popular view was that of ‘‘minduploaders’’, who believed all of a person’s vital data, including memories and perhaps genetic information, could eventually be ‘‘uploaded to the cloud’’ and stored forever.
Dr Shermer said the ‘‘really scary large’’ amount of information required was impossible to be gathered and stored.
Other limitations also meant the unique features of each person could not be captured in this way.
He took a more practical view of immortality, and favoured living well for a good lifespan.
‘‘Don’t worry about 500 years, just get to 100 with a healthy life,’’ he said.
During a vibrant question and answer session, he took issue with reported sightings of ghosts in English castles, and said ‘‘they never go to 7Eleven’’ convenience stores.
Old buildings tended to creak and move about a great deal, and imperfections in older generations of video cameras tended to generate some ghostlike images at times, he said.
Dr Shermer founded The Skeptics Society, and is editorinchief of its magazine Skeptic.
Conference codirectors Prof Bering and Prof Jamin Halberstadt, of the Otago psychology department, said the gathering had gone well, and had featured its strongest overall lineup over overseas speakers.