Auditor-General steps aside
Martin Matthews to stand down during an inquiry into his role in a major fraud scandal
The man tasked with preserving trust in the highest levels of Government has been forced to stand down while his handling of a major fraud scandal is investigated.
In a highly unusual case, AuditorGeneral Martin Matthews volunteered to step aside so his suitability for the role could be reviewed by an independent investigator.
A cross-party group of MPs agreed with Matthews’ request yesterday, as ongoing revelations about his oversight of a fraud case at the Ministry of Transport put increasing pressure on one of the nation’s top watchdogs.
“I think what is at risk here is the integrity of the Office of the AuditorGeneral,” Speaker of the House David Carter said yesterday afternoon.
Senior public servant Sir Maarten Wevers will lead the review. He is expected to report back within a fortnight. Over the past week Opposition MPs had raised concerns about whether Matthews failed to pick up or act on fraudulent activity in his former role as Secretary of Transport.
Matthews led the ministry while former senior manager Joanne Harrison stole $750,000 through fake invoices. She was jailed for three years and four months in February.
This week, Carter stood by Matthews, saying the Serious Fraud Office had described his performance as exemplary during the fraud investigation into Harrison.
Carter yesterday said he still had complete confidence in Matthews.
“No information has been presented to me that leaves me to doubt that confidence,” he said.
That position was echoed by Assistant Speaker and Labour MP Trevor Mallard. “We’re not going to hang the Auditor-General without a proper look,” he said.
Matthews is answerable to Parliament, not the Government, and his appointment this year was supported by all parties. The appointment process took the extraordinary step of hearing from the SFO about his handling of the Harrison case.
But the SFO’s briefing was limited to events after April 2016, when the agency opened its case into Harrison.
Documents released since she was convicted show ministry staff had alerted Matthews to Harrison’s un- usual activities as early as 2013.
Wevers’ inquiry will dig deeper. He would “go back as far as he needs to”.
Matthews said he stood by his actions, which were based on the information available to him at the time. “However, the current media coverage about these matters has the potential to undermine the important constitutional role of the Controller and Auditor-General.”
The Deputy Auditor-General, Greg Schollum, will take over while Matthews is being investigated.
Earlier yesterday the State Services Commission announced it was taking over an inquiry into whether staff at the ministry lost their jobs after raising concerns about Harrison’s behaviour. That inquiry had been led by the Transport Ministry but its handling of the probe had been criticised by former staff.