Weinstein trial rattles accusers
Evidence in New York sex assault trial reverberates across America
Harvey Weinstein’s sexual assault trial is unfolding in a 15th-floor courtroom in New York, but its reverberations are being felt far beyond, as his many accusers anxiously await the outcome.
They wonder how the disgraced mogul’s wealth and power might affect the verdict. They wince at the way fellow accusers have been treated while testifying. They recoil at the painfully familiar descriptions of Weinstein’s behaviour. And they wonder if they will ever see justice done.
The former Hollywood studio boss insists all of his sexual encounters were consensual, and the defence has portrayed the accusers who have testified as willing partners in a transactional exchange: Weinstein wanted sex, while they wanted to get ahead in the entertainment industry. The defence attacks have been so visceral at times that one woman broke down on the stand this week, unable to continue.
As they follow the trial from afar, some of Weinstein’s accusers — those whose stories will never reach a courtroom, because of statutes of limitation — have spoken to the Associated Press about the mix of emotions they are feeling: Hope, that Weinstein will be punished; fear, that he could be acquitted and regain his kingpin status in the movie business; and relief, that this case and the #MeToo movement it launched have made an indelible impact on society.
“There are many, many women who are waiting to see what happens,” said Erika Rosenbaum from her home in Canada.
For Louisette Geiss, only one ending to the Weinstein saga will bring real closure: Jail time.
“Otherwise, it will simply be like pulling off a scab,” the Los Angelesbased Geiss said of watching the trial unfold. “And it will send a signal to all predators: ‘You’re going to get away with it’.”
Weinstein, who amassed outsize power by producing a string of critically acclaimed, Oscar-winning films, is charged with sexually assaulting a production assistant in 2006 and raping a young actress in 2013. The charges involve just two of the scores of women who have accused him of sexual misconduct. Most of those cases are too old to prosecute.
Accuser Katherine Kendall sat through Annabella Sciorra’s crossexamination early in the trial, as the Sopranos actress — one of four women brought in to show Weinstein was a serial abuser — described the mogul forcing his way into her apartment and raping her in the 1990s. Kendall, at 23, had endured what she calls a terrifying night of her own at Weinstein’s apartment in New York in 1993.
Seeing Weinstein in court was wrenching.
“He’s so diminished. And it got to me, for a minute,” said Kendall, now 50, also based in Los Angeles. “But what he did to everyone got to me more. He wrecked so many women’s lives. It has to be accounted for.”
For Caitlin Dulaney, following the trial online has been overwhelming.
She said Weinstein exposed himself to her during the Cannes Film Festival in 1996.
“It’s very visceral. My heart will start beating and I sometimes need to take a moment,” said Dulaney, who lives in Los Angeles. “While it’s very personal, there’s also a lot at stake. A conviction for any of these charges to me would give me some hope that our system is catching up with modern culture.”
Louise Godbold, who said Weinstein sexually assaulted her after she sought an internship in 1991, isn’t sure that justice is yet available in the court system.
“But, in a global sense, justice to me is that his power and influence is taken away,” said Godbold, 57, of Los Angeles.
Rosenbaum, like others, fears a chilling effect on sex assault victims if Weinstein is acquitted.
“People are wondering, ‘Should I report’?” she said. “And if all these . . . voices can’t get [Weinstein] a day of jail time, they might think, ‘What’s the point of me telling on my uncle, telling on my coach, or the teacher who assaulted me?”’
Jasmine Lobe worries that Weinstein could return to his former perch in the industry.
“The fear isn’t that he could go on and assault other women,” said Lobe, a New York-based columnist for the Observer who said Weinstein attacked her in a hotel room in 2006. “It’s that there could be friends that he has, ready to help build him up again and put him back in power.”
Geiss, too, fears that Weinstein could regain some of his clout. And that, she said, would be a setback not only for accusers like her but for the next generation of women in Hollywood and for girls like her own daughters.
“The notion that he should go back to work and have a second chance is ludicrous,” she said.
And yet, the accusers feel that whatever happens in the New York trial — and with another case pending in Los Angeles — the Weinstein saga has changed the cultural landscape.
“Women have spoken out and will continue to speak out,” said Rosenbaum. “I don’t think there’s any going back.”
Geiss said that even though she would be bitterly disappointed in an acquittal, she feels “blessed that in my lifetime, we are tackling it”. She is saving magazine clippings and newspaper articles so when her daughters are older, “We’ll have the conversation, and they’ll turn to me in shock and awe that we had to go through this.”