Peace should pay dividends

The sudden cessation of war in Afghanistan should generate a budgetary “peace dividend” in the Five Eyes (FVEY) and EU countries.

Fiscal resources tagged for future military expenditures for Afghanistan can now be reallocated to peacetime uses.

The natural, indeed compelling, use of peace dividends would be for environmental protection.

Of course this requires actual reductions in military expenditures/ activities coupled with equivalent increases in expenditures for protecting/ improving the environment.

We should once again punch above our weight and engender discussions among the FVEY and EU countries on identifying peace dividends and reallocating them to improving the environment.

Robert Myers, Auckland Central.

Sydney similarities

My heart goes out to the victims and to all New Zealanders.

I get a sense that the terrorist attack in the Auckland supermarket in which seven people were injured, three critically, has parallels with the Sydney Lindt Cafe siege and terrorist attack by lone gunman Man Haron Monis on December 15-16, 2014 in which four were injured and three died, including the perpetrator.

In both cases, it seems the system failed society. Although the perpetrator was on the police radar as a violent potential terrorist, the system (the law and human rights regime, etc) allowed him to walk freely on the streets.

There is something fundamentally wrong in that. The system needs to change to protect innocent law-abiding citizens.

Rajend Naidu, Sydney, NSW.

Failure to legislate

All our thoughts are with the victims and their family/wha¯nau during these terrible days.

The simple point is this Government did not legislate to stop this. It had all the power in the world to do that and had specific information of a very high-risk offender posing the most serious of risk to an indeterminate class. Instead, it sat on its hands. Now it seeks to “duck and dive” out of this.

Let’s call it what it is — gross incompetence by this Government.

This Government needs to stand up and be accountable.

Adina Thorn, St Heliers.

Damaged minds

When persons apply for refugee status, should one of the requirements be a vigorous assessment of their mental conditions? Obviously, they do usually come from countries where their lives could have been stressful.

This latest situation reminds me of the woman from overseas who attacked pilots on a plane and said she would do it again if she had the opportunity.

Sue Gallahar, Ma¯ngere East.

Australian example

We cannot defend moral outrage at Australia for transporting non-citizen troublemakers before social harm is perpetrated, when our approach is to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars in keeping a potential offender in police crosshairs and then summarily executing him the moment he commits the expected social harm.

Ian Brady, Titirangi.

Difficult clients

The family of the 23-year-old male, who escaped from the Ellerslie quarantine facility and made his way home to

ta¯huhu, found itself in an awful situation but did the right thing. The police were called and he was returned to quarantine. The distressed mother has since apologised to the public for her son’s actions.

The ugly side of what staff at a MIQ facility have to deal with was demonstrated by the tirade of abuse aimed at staff by a woman upset about a pizza. Furthermore, she says she has no regrets and would do it all again. I think we all need to spare a thought for the staff in these quarantine facilities at such a difficult time.

Lorraine Kidd, Warkworth.

Distant lesson

May I add my voice to those who worry about MIQ facilities being located in Auckland itself, rather than outside the city? Our current experience with Delta and the resulting disruptions illustrate the issue pretty well.

Even the ancients knew that it was unwise to place ill and possibly contagious people amongst or near everyone else. The Greek physician, Hippocrates (460-377 BC), located his famous medical centre (Asclepieion) 5km away from the main town of Kos. He obviously knew a thing or two.

B. Watkin, Devonport.

Controlled arrivals

This time last year we should have started building a MIQ Centre, which is designed for purpose: secure and serviced by medical staff. A friend suggested Whenuapai Air Force Base, with an established security fence, manned by armed soldiers. That should deter all except the very stupid.

The expertise of a medical team servicing the MIQ Centre is crucial to success, the only group with the necessary skill sets. All visitors to New Zealand should land at Whenuapai and serve their isolation period, with no exemptions for rich listers.

Time to get building.

In the short term, use the campervan method at the Whenuapai Base.

After all, it is spring, heading into summer.

Meanwhile, use some of this “wage subsidy” to give the real essential workers a pay increase: supermarket staff, petrol station workers and most definitely all people working in hospitals and rest homes.

Malcolm Haig, Cambridge.

Envious abroad

Don’t be fooled by the complaints in the UK Times about Australia’s lockdowns ( NZ Herald, September 3). People here are envious of the success of New Zealand and Australia in controlling Covid.

Polls show two-thirds of our population want stricter measures if cases continue to rise. We have had over 130,000 dead, a million with long Covid and still, at the present rate, 7000 are dying every 10 weeks. The vaccines are losing efficiency and we run the risk of producing more dangerous mutations. Keep yourselves safe and we wish we had policies as effective as yours.

Greg Philo, Glasgow.

Hand outs

Michael Barnett ( NZ Herald, September 3) writes, “business owners in lockdown . . . still had to pay rent rates power and other overheads” and asks the Government to sort out their problems.

These are just business to business squabbles and businesses should be able to sort it out without mother stepping in. Business is already one of our biggest beneficiary groups and should be learning to stand on its own two feet.

Mark Nixon, Remuera.

Small contribution

There doesn’t seem to be a lot of positivity at the moment in Aotearoa. The stress of level four lockdown, an individual spewing hate-filled ideology through a knife attack in West Auckland, and a very selfish and silly young man deliberately disregarding the safety of others. There are probably more egregious things going on out there in the world, but because New Zealand has remained relatively unscathed from the world’s catastrophes, it felt heart-wrenching nevertheless.

Maybe naively, I believe in the power of small graces. Things that redeem the human spirit. So I made a modest donation to the Starship Foundation. It’s not a lot, it won’t change the world, but it made me feel I was helping to counter all the negativity out there at the moment. I would urge anyone who is able, to make a donation big or small, to their favourite charity. I promise you, it will make you feel a whole lot better.

Mary Hearn, Glendowie.

American motives

Matt Robson claims, ( NZ Herald, September 3), “the United States has been an interventionist power and will continue to be one but decidedly not for liberal or humanitarian reasons”. Try telling that to the millions liberated from Nazi bondage in 1944 or to those Germans assisted during the “Berlin airlift” following WWII.

The support given Japan in their postwar recovery, all initiatives of US foreign policy. Australia, NZ, both threatened by imperial Japan in 1942, our freedom secured by US military presence.

Without exception it is the US in the vanguard in assisting nations in dire need of humanitarian aid, their intentions honourable. We indeed have short memories.

P J Edmondson, Tauranga.