OPINION Let us be worthy bearers of the Treaty principals
Despite debate on interpretations, trust at its core
Historian Michael King pored over all the documentation around the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi and came to the conclusion the document fulfilled its singular original purpose.
That purpose was to allow William Hobson to govern.
“Hobson would have been utterly unable to govern the country, with a mere 4000 pounds, 39 officials, and 11 ‘alcoholic’ New South Wales police troopers, had Māori not given their consent. At any time Māori could withdraw their consent, as they did on various occasions in the 1840s and 1860s, and the civil and military authorities were unable to establish or fully regain control over those parts of the country where ‘rebellions’ occurred.”
So we know why the Crown drew up and offered the Treaty. But why did Māori sign it?
King continues “the Treaty appeared to offer Māori certain guarantees, and many Māori had formed their own view of what these guarantees were and pronounced them acceptable.”
This is where we sit today, 183 years on. A deal was drawn up and accepted by a majority of those around at the time. Some say the unwritten expectations, particularly on the part of Māori, are what divide us. Today, it would be more useful to consider that these matters are what unite us.
It is not difficult to imagine what the expectations of Māori were. Indeed, Hobson is likely to have known, or at least suspected, that some were over-inflated or unlikely to be realised. But it suited his needs to set that aside while getting about the business of governing, first in the Bay of Islands and then in Auckland.
King points out that the Treaty process met internationally recognised constitutional procedures but there were “loose ends” that have fuelled debate over the ensuing 180 years.
Some of these are: that Hobson’s proclamation of sovereignty preceded the collection of Treaty signatures; that some chiefs of large tribes declined to sign the document, or were not asked to; that more than one version of the Treaty was in circulation and subsequently signed; that there were inherent contradictions between even the “official” English and Māori versions; and that some Māori, with missionary encouragement, regarded the Treaty as being in the nature of a “sacred covenant” in the Biblical sense between themselves and Queen Victoria.
All these matters add elements to the conversation but do not override the principle that a Treaty was agreed to and signed between two parties — a majority of Māori representation and the Crown on behalf of the settlers, described subsequently by High Court Judge Eddie Durie as “tāngata tiriti”.
Māori invested whakapono, or trust, in the Treaty. Hobson got what he wanted but few would argue Māori did. This remains unresolved and is one key purpose for Waitangi Day: an opportunity to reflect on what we have done well and what more can be achieved.
The Treaty, King opines, was “neither a firm foundation for the construction of a state nor a blueprint for relations between governments and an indigenous people”. It was a pragmatic arrangement to allow a colony to be governed.
However, the Treaty was drawn up with “internationally recognised constitutional procedures” on encouragement from Colonial Office officials such as James Stephen and Lord Glenelg, slavery abolitionists whose concern for the welfare of Māori was “genuine and profound”, according to King. Their desire was to protect Māori rights and their property.
Some argue that New Zealand today is now a multicultural society and we have moved beyond our bicultural beginnings. But, in fact, the Treaty holds that we are an arrangement between two people — Māori and tāngata tiriti.
The debate over interpretations and intentions is part and parcel of what it is to be a New Zealander. It is both a burden and a privilege. May we bear it with pride and, this Waitangi Day, may we be worthy bearers of it.
and
4 What is the main spirit used in a
pin˜a colada?
5 For what sport is US athlete Sloane
Stephens famous?
6 Kākāriki is a Māori word for what
colour?
7 What country music singersongwriter was born Eilleen Regina Edwards in Canada in 1965?
8 By what name was Superman known on his home planet of Krypton?
9 In Greek mythology, who is queen
of the gods and Zeus’ wife?
10 In which New Zealand town would you find the Hundertwasser Pubic Toilets?
History
1778 During the American Revolutionary War, the United States wins official recognition and military support from France with the signing of a Treaty of Alliance in Paris.
1815 The state of New Jersey issues the first American railroad charter to John Stevens, who proposes a rail link between Trenton and New Brunswick. (The line, however, was never built.)
1840 The Treaty of Waitangi is signed by more than 40 Māori chiefs with the British Crown in the Bay of Islands.
1871 Otago Girls’ High School is opened, the first public girls’ secondary school in the southern hemisphere.
1947 The transtasman liner Wanganella is refloated in Wellington Harbour after striking a reef 18 days earlier. Carrying 400 passengers from Sydney the incident happens in calm seas and everyone on board is safely evacuated.
1952 Britain’s King George VI, 56, dies at Sandringham House in Norfolk, England; he was succeeded as monarch by his 25-year-old elder daughter, who became Queen Elizabeth II.
1998 President Bill Clinton signs a bill changing the name of Washington National Airport to Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
Birthdays
● Actor Mike Farrell is 84
● Rock singer Axl Rose (Guns N’ Roses) is 61
● Singer Rick Astley is 57
● Actor Ben Lawson is 43
Quiz Answers
1 You Keep Me Hangin’ On,
2 Pōhutukawa, 3 Sandra Bullock,
4 Rum, 5 Tennis, 6 Green, 7 Shania Twain, 8 Kal-El, 9 Hera, 10 Kawakawa
Complaints
This newspaper is subject to the NZ Media Council. First email a complaint to editor@ northernadvocate.co.nz. If not satisfied, go to mediacouncil.org.nz.