India-China border dispute: A conflict that has been years in the making
The most violent encounter in decades between the Chinese and Indian armies arrayed along a disputed border high in the Himalayas did not involve any exchange of gunfire.
Instead, soldiers from the two nuclear-armed nations fashioned weapons from what they could find in the desolate landscape, some 4000m above sea level.
Wielding fence posts and clubs wrapped in barbed wire, they squared off under a moonlit sky along jagged cliffs soaring high above the Galwan Valley, fighting for hours in pitched hand-to-hand battles.
Some Indian soldiers died after tumbling into the river in the valley below. Others were beaten to death. By the next day, 20 Indian troops were dead. It remains unclear if there were Chinese casualties.
The two countries’ soldiers are not allowed to carry guns in the area, a reflection of the depth of the bad blood that courses through the ranks of the military forces on both sides in the disputed territory.
The clash on Monday night, fought in one of the most forbidding landscapes on the planet, was a startling culmination of months of mounting tension and years of dispute.
And it comes at a fraught moment, with the world focused on battling the coronavirus and with the nationalist leaders of both nations eager to flex their muscles.
Here’s a look at how both nations arrived at this juncture, the battles that came before and how the New York Times covered the conflict.
1914: A border China never agreed to
The conflict stretches back to at least
1914, when representatives from Britain, the Republic of China and Tibet gathered in Simla, in what is now India, to negotiate a treaty that would determine the status of Tibet and effectively settle the borders between China and British India.
The Chinese, baulking at proposed terms that would have allowed Tibet to be autonomous, refused to sign the deal. But Britain and Tibet signed a treaty establishing what would be called the McMahon Line, named after a British colonial official, Henry McMahon, who proposed the border.
India maintains that the McMahon Line, an 885km frontier that extends through the Himalayas, is the legal border between China and India.
But China has never accepted it.
1962: India and China go to war
In 1947, India declared its independence from Britain. Two years later, the Chinese revolutionary Mao Zedong proclaimed an end to his country’s Communist Revolution and founded the People’s Republic of China.
Almost immediately, the two countries — now the world’s most populous — found themselves at odds over the border. Tensions rose throughout the 1950s. The Chinese insisted that Tibet was never independent and could not have signed a treaty creating an international border. There were several failed attempts at peaceful negotiation.
China sought to control critical roadways near its western frontier in Xinjiang, while India and its Western allies saw any attempts at Chinese incursion as part of a wider plot to export Maoist-style Communism across the region.
By 1962, war had broken out. Chinese troops crossed the McMahon Line and took up positions deep in Indian territory, capturing mountain passes and towns. The war lasted one month but resulted in more than 1000 Indian deaths and over 3000 Indians taken as prisoners. The Chinese military suffered fewer than 800 deaths.
By November, Premier Zhou Enlai of China declared a cease-fire, unofficially redrawing the border near where Chinese troops had conquered territory. It was the socalled Line of Actual Control.
1967: India pushes China back Tensions came to a head again in 1967 along two mountain passes, Nathu La and Cho La, that connected Sikkim — then a kingdom and a protectorate of India — and China’s Tibet Autonomous Region.
A scuffle broke out when Indian troops began laying barbed wire along what they recognised as the border. The scuffles soon escalated when a Chinese military unit began firing artillery shells at the Indians. In the ensuing conflict, more than 150 Indians and 340 Chinese were killed.
But India prevailed, destroying Chinese fortifications in Nathu La and pushing them farther back into their territory near Cho La. The change in positions, however, meant that China and India each had different and conflicting ideas about the location of the Line of Actual Control.
The fighting was the last time that troops on either side would be killed — until the skirmishes in the Galwan Valley on Monday night. Indian news outlets reported that Chinese soldiers had also been killed, but Beijing was tight-lipped.
It would be 20 more years before India and China clashed again at the disputed border.
In 1987, the Indian military was conducting a training operation to see how fast it could move troops to the border. The large number of troops arriving next to Chinese outposts surprised Chinese commanders — who responded by advancing toward what they considered the Line of Actual Control. Realising the potential to start a war, both India and China deescalated, and a crisis was averted.
2013: Push comes to shove Cat-and-mouse tactics unfolded on both sides. After decades of patrolling the border, a Chinese platoon pitched a camp near Daulat Beg Oldi in April
2013. The Indians soon followed, setting up their own base fewer than
300m away.
By May, the sides had agreed to dismantle both encampments, but disputes about the location of the Line of Actual Control persisted.
2017: Bhutan caught in the middle In June 2017, the Chinese set to work building a road in the Doklam Plateau,
an area of the Himalayas controlled not by India, but by its ally Bhutan. The plateau lies on the border of Bhutan and China, but India sees it as a buffer zone that is close to other disputed areas with China.
Indian troops carrying weapons and operating bulldozers confronted the Chinese with the intention of destroying the road. A standoff ensued, soldiers threw rocks at each other and troops from both sides suffered injuries.
In August, the countries agreed to withdraw from the area, and China stopped construction on the road.
2020: Brawls break out
In May, melees broke out several times. In one clash at the glacial lake Pangong Tso, Indian troops were badly inured and had to be evacuated by helicopter. Indian analysts said Chinese troops were injured as well.
China bolstered its forces with dump trucks, excavators, troop carriers, artillery and armoured vehicles, Indian experts said.
President Donald Trump offered on Twitter to mediate what he called “a raging border dispute”.
What was clear was that it was the most serious series of clashes between the two sides since 2017 — and a harbinger of the deadly confrontation to come. New York Times