Daughter visits location mum’s remains found
Discovery in ‘godforsaken place’ offers some closure, but raises more questions
A DNA match has confirmed a skeleton found in a remote area of Porirua belongs to a woman who went missing from the nearby psychiatric hospital 36 years ago.
But a visit to the “godforsaken place” where the remains were found has left the woman’s daughter with more questions than answers.
Hilary Martin had earlier told the Herald she believed her mother had died by suicide, having previously told her family if she had to go back to Porirua Hospital she would disappear and nobody would ever find her.
But Martin said a visit to the site had left her questioning how her mother, Patricia Burt, was able to travel rugged terrain and a steep slope in slippers and with osteoporosis to reach the spot where she was eventually found.
The officer in charge of the investigation, Detective Senior Sergeant Hamish Blackburn, said police had uncovered no evidence of foul play or suspicious activity.
“I said to Hilary ‘we are never going to fully understand or have the answers as to how [she] came to be there’,” he said.
Burt, 68, disappeared on Easter weekend 1988. Her family said she was never searched for, and a police officer at the time told them they did not look for people who went missing from Porirua Hospital.
Martin earlier told the Herald her mother had struggled with mental health issues her entire life and been taken to Porirua Hospital many times, where she received electroshock therapy.
Martin said police had since told her Burt had been diagnosed with dementia right before she disappeared.
She and her family believed her mother had died by suicide, but after visiting the site in Porirua’s Whitireia Park in March, she now believed something suspicious had happened to Burt, or that she may have died by “misadventure”.
“The site was far too difficult for anybody to get there. Someone would have to be an Olympian or very fit person to be able to climb the rugged hill we climbed,” she said.
Police escorted Martin and her husband to the site in a 4WD, through a locked gate and high up a ridge, which they then had to climb down to the area where the remains were found.
Neither she nor her husband felt they would have been able to access the area without police help, even in their youth. Even reaching the top of the ridge in the 4WD was difficult. Martin thinking at one point the vehicle might tip
She said it was a shock to realise how hard the spot was to reach, and did not believe her mother could have gone there on her own.
“I would have to say it was like a mountain, looking down the slope.
“You would have to see it to believe it, it was a godforsaken place . . . that’s why the skeleton was never found.
“I believe, and so does [my husband], that something suspicious happened . . . if you’re going to plan suicide, you don’t plan the most remote place in the world, where the terrain is so difficult. You just couldn’t do it.”
Martin said the realisation was “very upsetting”.
“We were hoping that it would be comforting to see that was her resting place, but it became disturbing.”
Police initially identified Burt by items found with her at the scene, including a medical bracelet and a denture case.
An initial DNA test came back inconclusive, but the second DNA test, which came back last week, confirmed a match with Burt’s son.
Martin said police had also removed Burt’s slippers to discover two of her toes were missing — which lined up with the knowledge she had had two toes amputated earlier in her life.
She said her mother’s skull was found 2m away from the rest of her skeleton, and her “beautiful piano hands” were missing. It is possible over 36 years these were scavenged by animals, and that the skull could naturally have separated and moved further away over that time.
“She could have fallen from the top and rolled down. Maybe the neck was broken and that’s why the skull separated,” she said.
“There are 101 possibilities what happened to Mum on the day she went missing, but the main issue is we found her skeleton after 36 years.”
Blackburn told the Herald there were “a number of possibilities”, but the most logical was that Burt had made her way to the park and taken her own life.
“I guess with her history of mental illness and the previous comments around suicide and ‘if I go to the hospital again I will never be found’, that perhaps that was her intention. I guess we will never fully understand the reasons why.”
He said the area was isolated, but people did walk along the coastline at the bottom of the hill.
“How she came to be up on the hill we don’t know.
“There’s nothing that we’ve uncovered in this investigation that would lead us to believe there was anything suspicious.”
He said the remains were found in dense bushes and undergrowth.
“It was quite hard to see. The bones were covered in moss and lots of foliage.”
The bones were found by a man searching for nesting seabirds.
“We reached out to a missing persons unit based at Police National Headquarters, and they gave us a list of missing people since the first of January 1980. They actually nominated Patricia Burt as a possible because she had been missing in the area.”
By the time police recovered the items at the scene, they knew they were on the right track.
“Those pieces of the puzzle were starting to come together nicely.”
The investigation had been “challenging” and Blackburn said the skeleton was an uncommon find.
“From time to time we find parts of bones that we can link back to missing people, but in terms of a mostly complete skeleton, it doesn’t happen too often at all.
“After 36 years it’s very pleasing for us to be able to confirm that it’s Patricia Burt, very pleasing to be able to get some closure for them. It was nice to be able to take Hilary and her husband up to the scene and show them exactly where she was.”
Martin said despite being uncertain how her mother ended up where she did, they now had “some closure” and she was “feeling very blessed that she’s been found after all these years”.
The remains would be released to the family once the coroner’s work was done.
“We will bury her ashes with Dad at the Taita¯ Soldiers Cemetery in Naenae. We did have a small ceremony for Mum back in the ’90s.”
We were hoping that it would be comforting to see that was her resting place, but it became disturbing. Hilary Martin, daughter of Patricia Burt