Robertson’s strategy under fire as Mo’unga eyes return

The recent moves by New Zealand Rugby powerbrokers regarding Richie Mo’unga’s potential return have left many fans feeling for domestic contenders.

Scott Robertson’s apparent eagerness to bring back players from overseas and move David Havili into first-five for the Crusaders leads to concerns about the depth of talent in New Zealand, especially at the pivot position.

Robertson’s visit to Japan to meet Mo’unga and the subsequent efforts to coax him back ahead of schedule reflects a sense of apprehension in the established playmaking stocks.

It comes after the Herald revealed in March that Robertson had tried to lure Sam Whitelock back into the All Blacks fold and adds another layer to the narrative surrounding his approach to building his new team.

Robertson’s endeavours to entice proven test players from overseas suggest a willingness to bend the rules to his advantage rather than focusing solely on bolstering New Zealand’s talent pool and fostering domestic talent development.

The potential return of established players like Mo’unga undoubtedly casts a shadow of uncertainty over those vying for the pivotal first-five position, such as Damian McKenzie and Stephen Perofeta.

McKenzie, who has yet to fully assert his authority in the All Blacks No 10 jersey, having started five tests in that position, faces the daunting task of proving himself to a new coach amid speculation about the return of a seasoned campaigner.

The sentiments echoed by fans on social media reflect a broader concern about the direction in which New Zealand rugby is heading. The expectation was for Robertson to usher in a new era of creativity and dynamism.

While the allure of experienced campaigners such as Whitelock and Mo’unga may be undeniable, it raises questions about the long-term vision for the All Blacks and the balance between immediate success and sustainable growth.

Robertson’s efforts to bring back the pair underscore a strategic approach aimed at maximising shortterm gains but it remains to be seen whether such manoeuvres align with the broader objectives of nurturing homegrown talent and maintaining the integrity of All Blacks selection.

The rugby landscape is rich with promising players eager to make their mark on the international stage. With the next World Cup more than three years away, those prospects must be given a chance.

There’s no denying Mo’unga’s and Whitelock’s talent. Still, it’s crucial to question whether such a move aligns with the need for fresh perspectives and new strategies, especially with the 2027 World Cup in mind.