No immunity for MP or MLA for taking bribes: Top court
A seven-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court on Monday ruled that an MP or MLA cannot claim immunity from prosecution on a charge of bribery in connection with the vote or speech in the Parliament or Legislative Assembly.
In an unanimous view, the SC’S Constitution Bench overruled the 1998 judgement in the P V Narasimha Rao case.
“We disagree with the judgment in P V Narasimha case which grants immunity to legislator for alleged bribery for making a speech or vote in a particular manner in the House that has wide ramifications,” Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud observed during the hearing.
The top court held that corruption and bribery by legislators destroy the functioning of Indian parliamentary democracy. The bench headed by the CJI said that the bribery is not
rendered immune citing Article 105 or 194.
“A member indulging in bribery indulges in a criminal act which is not essential for casting a vote or giving a speech in the legislature,” the CJI said.
The Supreme Court said that the interpretation of P V Narasimha judgment is contrary to Articles 105 and 194 of the constitution. The court said
that interpretation which has been placed on the issue in question and the judgment of the majority in P V Narasimha Rao results in a paradoxical outcome where a legislator is conferred with immunity when they accept a bribe and follow through by voting in the agreed direction.
The interpretation of P V Narasimha judgement is contrary to Articles 105 and 194, the CJI added.
Chief Justice Chandrachud further observed that the offence of bribe is crystallised on the taking of illegal gratification and it does not depend on whether the vote or speech is given later.
Speaking after the verdict, Advocate Ashwini Upadhyay said that the apex court through its judgment made it clear that if any legislator takes bribes to ask questions or cast vote in the legislature will not be immune to prosecution.
The lawyer said that the accused legislator will not be treated with any special protocols but will be charged with corruption.
“The Supreme Court ruled that the asking questions or casting votes by taking bribes will be equivalent to destroying India’s parliamentary democracy,” the lawyer said.