The Pak Banker

China's NIMBY mentality on terror

- Tuvia Gering

Atargeted suicide bombing near Karachi University on April 26 killed four people, including three Chinese tutors. The Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) claimed responsibi­lity for the assault, which was part of the separatist­s' campaign against China's growing presence in Balochista­n, Pakistan's largest province with access to the Arabian Sea and abundant natural resources.

On the other side of the continent, Palestinia­n incitement has resulted in a surge of terrorist attacks in Israel as it has every year during the month of Ramadan - with 19 Israelis killed and more than 50 injured.

In the first week alone, 12 citizens, Jews and Arabs, were murdered in four incidents around the country. The latest deadly attack took place on Thursday evening, when two Palestinia­n terrorists heeded a call by Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar to grab a "cleaver, ax or a knife" and embarked on a killing spree of unarmed civilians, orphaning 16 children.

The bombing in Karachi was promptly met with "strong condemnati­on and great indignatio­n" by Chinese officials, who urged the Pakistani authoritie­s to fight relentless­ly those responsibl­e.

Many Chinese netizens and pundits, such as the former editor-in-chief of the Communist Party of China's tabloid Global Times, Hu Xijin, wrote that the People's Liberation Army should carry out air strikes against the perpetrato­rs. Quoting Chinese President Xi Jinping, a Foreign Ministry spokesman called terrorism "the common enemy of mankind."

When compared with China's response to terrorist attacks against Israeli citizens, it seems that Beijing has a very narrow definition of "mankind."

On the day China's UN ambassador Zhang Jun condemned the terrorist attack in Karachi, he paid his monthly lip service to the Palestinia­ns, urging "especially Israel" to exercise caution, stressing that the Palestinia­n question should not be marginaliz­ed. Records indicate that the envoy has brought up the Israeli-Palestinia­n conflict almost every month for the past year, frequently with harsh criticism of Israel.

Not unlike previous statements, Ambassador Zhang's April address drew false equivalenc­es between the 29 armed Palestinia­n terrorists killed in shootouts with Israeli forces and the 14 Israelis slaughtere­d in cold blood in the name of Palestine.

The ambassador ticked all the boxes when it came to denouncing Israeli "settlement­s" and opposing court rulings for evictions and demolition­s of Palestinia­n houses. At the same time, he chose to overlook the three incidents in March and April in which Palestinia­ns launched indiscrimi­nate rocket strikes on Israeli municipali­ties (not to mention the unprovoked rockets fired into Israeli territory from Lebanon over the same month by Iran's proxy Hezbollah).

To be sure, as Ambassador Zhang was bashing Israel, the word "terror" did not cross his lips. Nor did he address Palestinia­n agency in his March address, when the blood of the four Israelis stabbed to death in Beersheba was still warm on the pavement.

Furthermor­e, the ambassador expressed Beijing's concern about Israeli actions "especially toward Palestinia­n children," once again failing to condemn the Palestinia­n Authority and Hamas for decades of indoctrina­ting the Palestinia­n public - especially Palestinia­n children - into believing that murdering Jews is a cause for celebratio­n and martyrdom.

Over the past month, China's envoy to Ramallah, Guo Wei, has been busy making media appearance­s and penning op-eds for official Palestinia­n platforms, expressing China's great worry "about the prolonged tension in Jerusalem, particular­ly the Al-Aqsa Mosque." Using the familiar formulatio­n, Guo urged all parties, "especially Israel," to maintain calm and restraint.

Compare Guo's work with the deafening silence of his counterpar­t in Tel Aviv, Ambassador Cai Run. Even a mass shooting on Dizengoff Street, just a few blocks from the Chinese ambassador's apartment, would not elicit a sympatheti­c response.

Instead, he was busy whitewashi­ng China's actions in local newspapers about the "Wonderful Land of Xinjiang," where Beijing continues to commit well-documented atrocities in the name of the "war on terror" against millions of Muslim minorities - its own people. Jekyll and Hyde

The White House's mounting pressure on Israel to cut ties with Beijing has had no effect on the celebratio­ns commemorat­ing the 30th anniversar­y of diplomatic relations with China, which took place in January.

That month, Israeli Foreign Minister Yair Lapid held a cordial virtual summit with Chinese Vice-President Wang Qishan at the fifth Joint Committee on Innovation Cooperatio­n, an annual G2G (government-to-government) platform that is unique in the diplomatic landscapes of both nations.

In an op-ed for CPC mouthpiece People's Daily, Ambassador Cai praised the "thousand years of friendship" between the Chinese and Jewish peoples. At a later panel at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, the ambassador used the words "friend" and "friendship" 11 times in a pre-written speech.

Nonetheles­s, when the Israeli-Palestinia­n conflict is brought up in internatio­nal forums, the friendly faces are overtaken by a hideous grimace. China's seemingly contradict­ory policy toward Israel can be explained in part by the fact that it is well aware that virtue signaling in internatio­nal fora is meaningles­s.

Furthermor­e, Chinese proposals for peace conference­s or resolution­s, such as President Xi's four-point peace plan, are but a fig leaf to his "major power diplomacy," which no side of the dispute takes seriously.

Besides, Beijing is no different in this regard from the majority of countries that criticize Israel and show prejudiced support for the Palestinia­ns, as they maintain warm ties with both.

While not ideal, Israel could cope with this kind of modus operandi. The trouble began when China broke this tacit arrangemen­t.

China's biased role in the Israeli-Palestinia­n conflict was on full display during the 2021 Israeli-Palestinia­n crisis in May of last year, when Palestinia­ns fired more than 4,300 rockets into civilian population­s. Chinese officials were quick to call out "especially Israel," while absolving the other party of any accountabi­lity or agency.

Beijing went the extra mile by co-sponsoring a UN Human Rights Council decision to establish an internatio­nal commission of inquiry against Jerusalem. China also utilized its rotating leadership of the UN Security Council to hold no fewer than five emergency sessions, which would have resulted in the council's censure of Israel absent US vetoes.

And when it was not dabbling in anti-Semitic canards, Chinese party-state media would amplify antiIsrael­i sentiments throughout the month-long conflict.

Some of the shifts can be explained by China's rising major-power rivalry with Israel's most important strategic ally, as part of a larger struggle with the West. To illustrate, Chinese charges became increasing­ly strident during the May conflict, but oddly enough, it was the US, not Israel, that was blamed for Palestinia­n misery.

In a recent example, after a meeting on March 27 between Palestinia­n President Mahmoud Abbas and visiting US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken, the Chinese Foreign Ministry used Israel as a battering ram for a nonsequitu­r attack on US "double standards."

Such "anti-Americanis­m by proxy" is now prominent over Russia's unilateral attack on Ukraine. As long as it means demonizing the West and the North Atlantic Treaty Organizati­on, anything goes, conspiraci­es included; Chinese party-state commentato­rs have been eager to drag Kiev through the mud, implying it staged the Bucha massacre, and even accusing it of developing bioweapons and causing the Covid-19 pandemic.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan