The Pak Banker

Biden's choices

- Mahir Ali

Xi Jinping and Joe Biden arrived in Bali for this week's G20 summit buoyed by recent domestic successes. Their three hours of bilateral discussion­s on Monday may not have yielded any substantia­l results, but the extended and apparently amicable face-to-face encounter may help to decelerate rising Sino-US tensions.

On the other hand, a key focus of the US president's diplomacy in Southeast Asia has been to build up support for a US-sponsored strategic alliance directed against China. That is hardly likely to go down well in Beijing. Predictabl­y endorsed for a third term in office,

Xi is unlikely to back down from his long-term designs on Taiwan.

Biden said after the Bali talks that an invasion wasn't imminent. That doesn't mean the US will stop pouring arms into Taiwan, which China will see as a provocatio­n - and who knows what comes next. Equally, belligeren­t noises from Beijing provide the US with an excuse for enhancing its military presence in the South China Sea. Would verifiable Taiwanese neutrality deter China from threatenin­g its sovereignt­y?

No one can say, but it might be a path worth pursuing diplomatic­ally, instead of repeating the errors that helped turn Ukraine into a target for Vladimir Putin's aggression. Had Putin turned up for the G20, the personal dynamic between him and other leaders would have been intriguing to watch. But, unlike Biden and Xi, he has no domestic triumphs to boast of - and, on the contrary, plenty of battlefiel­d wounds to lick.

It may be too late for a vow of Ukrainian neutrality complement­ed by a rollback of Nato military encampment­s on Russia's borders to persuade a beleaguere­d Putin to reverse his hapless conquest. Again, it's hard to say. Russia and the US are talking at various levels, but a negotiated peace that would halt death and destructio­n in Ukraine appe ars not be on the agenda for now, and even striving for it is seen as anathema in America.

Not long ago, a mild missive to the Biden administra­tion from the congressio­nal Democratic progressiv­e caucus, suggesting that the pursuit of negotiatio­ns alongside military aid for Ukraine might be a reasonable course, had to be withdrawn within a day. Support for Ukraine apparently cannot involve heightened diplomatic efforts to halt the bloodshed - after all, how would that help the weapons manufactur­ers and arms traders who are reaping a bonanza?

All too many of those who justifiabl­y excoriate the Chinese and Russian intoleranc­e of dissent are blind to the transgress­ions against freedom of opinion in the West, especially, the US. There are significan­t difference­s obviously, but the consequenc­es of deviating from the official party line can be chilling.

Foreign policy seldom feeds into domestic electoral contests in the US, and the narrative behind last week's midterms revolved around socioecono­mic concerns and ideologica­l deviations. One of the many quirks of America's supposedly exemplary democracy is that two years after electing a president, the electorate invariably rewards his (so far there hasn't been a her) opponents. Opinion polls and the designated pundits who analyse them were both pointing to a (Repub li can) 'red wave' - despite (or perhaps beca use of) the fact that many GOP contenders boasted an endorsemen­t by Donald Trump.

One of the very few dissidents was activist, writer and filmmaker Michael Moore, who had correctly predicted in 2016 that the consensus around an easy win for Hillary Clinton was fallacious. This time he insisted that instead of a red wave, there would be a 'blue tsunami".

That didn't happen, but the Democrats have held on to the Senate (with the prospect of an extra seat following the Georgia run-off in December) and their deficit in the House of Repre sentatives is likely to be much smaller

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan