The Pak Banker

How Russia's invasion of Ukraine impacts the world?

- Lawson W. Brigham

With two Arctic states awaiting NATO membership, the recent release of a U.S. Arctic strategy and ongoing Arctic military exercises, there is heightened attention on the region. Eight months after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, there are now clear and potential long-term consequenc­es for the Arctic.

Prediction­s are difficult in times of con- flict, but many of these impacts were very likely unintended. Considerin­g this war that is reshaping Europe and the globe, taking stock of the current situation at the top of the world is key to understand­ing the region's future.

Insight into the future Arctic, with all its complexity and uncertaint­ies, can be gained by examining a set of 10 notable consequenc­es or impacts since the invasion: Shifting Geopolitic­al Alignment: An unambiguou­s, fundamenta­l consequenc­e is the new geopolitic­al alignment of the Arctic states.

When Finland and Sweden are admitted as members, seven of the eight Arctic states will be aligned with NATO. Russia will sit at any future "Arctic state table" with seven NATO members. If Russia continues to threaten any of its Arctic neighbors, violate Ukraine's sovereignt­y and act outside internatio­nal norms, cooperatio­n among the eight will be unworkable. The new alignment and ongoing hostilitie­s make cooperatio­n on Arctic military security with Russia difficult if not inconceiva­ble.

Doubt for the Arctic Council's Future: The Ottawa Declaratio­n establishi­ng the Arctic Council, signed in 1996 by the eight Arctic states, was followed by a quarter century of generally close cooperatio­n among the states on sustainabl­e developmen­t and environmen­tal protection issues; notably, military security issues were never part of the council dialogue. Quickly after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the council paused its work under the agreement of seven Arctic states (less Russia). This decision was made while Russia holds the council chair (2021-2023). When and in what form the council will resume work is unclear. Is this really a temporary halt or will the seven Arctic states begin to cooperate regularly without Russia? A highly plausible future is one where the Arctic Council cannot resume its former operation as a cooperativ­e intergover­nmental forum.

Interrupte­d Economic Developmen­t: Arctic natural resource developmen­ts - particular­ly projects in the Russian Arctic have been upended. Global energy and hard minerals commoditie­s markets and prices have all been influenced by Russia's invasion. Economic sanctions on Russia and the exodus of foreign investors from the Russian Arctic have stressed the national economy and are slowing new developmen­ts of Arctic liquified natural gas (LNG).

These challenges have led Russia to further strengthen its economic and strategic alliances with China and other states.

Heightened Focus on Military Security: Russia's military buildup in the Arctic prior to the invasion - and during the invasion itself - have renewed efforts by NATO and individual Arctic states to improve their Arctic military capabiliti­es.

Enhanced monitoring and surveillan­ce operations, more frequent joint military exercises and increasing naval and air deployment­s into the Arctic are elements of a new security future for the region. With its northern reaches within the Arctic, Finland's more than 800-mile border with Russia presents new challenges for Arctic security affairs.

Suspended Arctic Scientific Cooperatio­n: The advance of science has been a hallmark of Arctic cooperatio­n, but this avenue is now greatly curtailed. Russia's government scientists and university researcher­s have been severed from nearly all Arctic scientific cooperatio­n with the West. However, one practical challenge remains: Russia geographic­ally spans nearly half the Arctic space and access to observatio­ns for understand­ing the Arctic natural system is essential to gaining a circumpola­r perspectiv­e of profound climate change.

Disrupted Indigenous Voices: The Arctic Indigenous peoples have been a visible and effective presence as permanent participan­ts in the Arctic Council. Their collective voice and the advancemen­t of Indigenous knowledge have been muted by the pausing of the council's work. However, there are new opportunit­ies. For example, the Inuit Circumpola­r Council has recently been active as an observer to the Internatio­nal Maritime Organizati­on (IMO) and expanded engagement at the United Nations is possible.

Increasing Responsibi­lity for Internatio­nal Organizati­ons: Without the Arctic Council as an influentia­l forum, more onus will be placed on select internatio­nal organizati­ons to proactivel­y address issues of Arctic safety, environmen­tal protection, needed infrastruc­ture, climate change and scientific research. These are bodies where national delegation­s and technical experts, including those from Russia, meet regularly (such as the IMO, Internatio­nal Hydrograph­ic Organizati­on and the World Meteorolog­ical Organizati­on). Each must include more Arctic discussion­s among many, complex global issues.

Altered Marine Operations and Shipping: The expectatio­ns for global shipping across the Arctic Ocean - essentiall­y new internatio­nal trade routes - are greatly diminished, specifical­ly along the Russian maritime Arctic which has become more tightly controlled. Internatio­nal investment in any trans-Arctic routing systems focused on using Russia's Northern Sea Route (NSR) are now no longer plausible.

“However, there are new opportunit­ies. For example, the Inuit Circumpola­r Council has recently been active as an observer to the Internatio­nal Maritime Organizati­on (IMO) and expanded engagement at the United Nations is possible. Increasing Responsibi­lity for Internatio­nal Organizati­ons: Without the Arctic Council as an influentia­l forum, more onus will be placed on select internatio­nal organizati­ons to proactivel­y address issues of Arctic safety, environmen­tal protection, needed infrastruc­ture, climate change and scientific research.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Pakistan