The Manila Times

Crooks in the courtrooms

-

fallen on deaf ears because we do not hear of lawyers coming out to presumably because the assurance of administra­tive amnesty and immunity were not enough for them to stake their career in line.

I knew of an incident when the lawyer was willing to take his chance at exposing the extortion by a prosecutor but his client did not approve of pursuing administra­tive and criminal complaints for fear of facing a more complicate­d pursuit of justice from the other courts in the city and still losing in the end.

The client was a foreign businessma­n who was duped into paying an initial P26 million for a P76-million estafa complaint against the seller. After nearly one year, the court found probable cause for indictment. When things turned awry.

The public prosecutor reached out to the businessma­n’s lawyer and asked for a sum. After negotiatio­ns, the businessma­n was forced to shell out P1.6 million in cash in the hope of getting a favorable resolution. It came at a time as Christmas was approachin­g. Obviously not content with the cash haul, the prosecutor suggested that the businessma­n express gratitude to the judge by sending her a Christmas gift. The businessma­n bought an original Louis Vuitton bag. However, when the bag was ready for pickup, the prosecutor changed her mind. She wanted the gift for the judge to be in cash.

The lawyer could no longer stand the situation. The businessma­n was mad and disappoint­ed. He went to court to recover the P26 million he paid initially for a property on which he planned to build a small resort hotel. But then he ended up falling victim to yet another crime—extortion expected could help him get justice.

With the integrity of the court compromise­d, the businessma­n sought to suspend the hearings on his case and asked that the judge inhibit herself. The motion was granted without much discussion of the “deportment” complained about. The case with the new judge, it was terminated at once.

Murmurs about corruption in the courts are not isolated. But when one faces too much uncertaint­y in getting justice and the possibilit­y of falling again for yet another layer of criminal activities, how can we expect them to speak up.

We have read or heard of a few other cases involving corruption in the courts, but we don’t know what happened after they were exposed in media.

Last March, for instance, a former lawyer of Janet Lim- Napoles, the suspected mastermind in the multibilli­on-peso pork-barrel scam, was arrested allegedly for selling fake Court of Appeals resolution­s, based on investigat­ion by the National Bureau of Investigat­ion (NBI).

- - trapment operation following the complaint of the mother of a man convicted of possession of illegal drugs and whose appeal was being heard in the Court of Appeals.

The NBI said receipts submitted as evidence against Ramon showed the complainan­t had given her close to P1 million for the resolution that turned out to be fake. The complainan­t’s family said they mortgaged their home to pay for a reversal of conviction but all the money went to the supposed gambling debts of Ramon. The NBI said Ramon also had faced various cases of selling fake resolution­s in housing cases, but these were eventually dropped after the complainan­ts failed to pursue the charges.

In another incident, a ranking public prosecutor in Quezon City was kicked out of his job for allegedly demanding money from a complainan­t in exchange for a favorable ruling and also for selling him tickets for a

The Office of the Ombudsman dismissed Quezon City Assistant City Prosecutor Edgar Navales for grave misconduct and subsequent­ly charged him with direct bribery in the Sandiganba­yan. Navales was also to one year’s salary.

Reports said Navales demanded P100,000 from Reynaldo de Leon, who in July 2014 filed a car theft case that was assigned to Navales, in exchange for an order upholding his complaint. The prosecutor also

In Nov. 2014, the NBI arrested Quezon City Assistant Prosecutor Raul Desembrana in an entrapment operation for allegedly extorting P80,000 from Dr. Alex Montes, a member of the so over suspicions of being members of the New People’s Army (NPA).

Reports said Desembrana asked for P80,000 from Montes in exchange for the dismissal of an unjust vexation chaplain against him.

There may be many more cases out there involving officers of the court entangled in extortion activities, targeting victims of criminal activities who went to court to seek redress and obtain justice. Corruption in the courts, just like sexual abuse involving religious leaders, is a reality widely known but hardly addressed.

With hopes high on the new ad - ruption and other criminal activities, we ought to do our part in pursuit of its success. The President, no matter how serious he may be, cannot do it alone.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Philippines