Present tense, future uncertain
Despite Taliban assurances, Afghans, especially women and minorities, are wary of what the future holds for them
During and after the recent takeover of Afghanistan, Taliban officials strenuously sought to project a responsible, moderate image of the group, almost 20 years after its removal from power.
Addressing the news media on Aug. 18 in Kabul, Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid pledged that the new government would respect the rights of women and grant amnesty to those who had resisted them, while promising that Afghanistan would never again become a safe haven for terrorists.
His comments echoed those of Shahabuddin Delawar, a senior Taliban negotiator, who said in Moscow on July 9 that the group would ensure that women and girls have the right to work and education, provided that those rights do not contravene the tenets of Islam.
Yet memories of Taliban rule in Afghanistan before the US invasion of 2001 remain a vivid cautionary tale, through photos and videos of militants flogging defenseless women encased in burqas, kneeling in the dust.
From 1996 to 2001, strict gender segregation was enforced by the Taliban, a predominantly Pashtun Islamic fundamentalist group that had filled the power vacuum in Afghanistan following a protracted civil war.
Once it had implemented its interpretation of Shariah, women were not allowed to leave their homes without a male relative, while girls over the age of seven were denied an education and often ended up being married off to much older men.
The system of gender apartheid instituted by the Taliban meant that women were required to wear the burqa every time they went out of the house.
Those who defied the rules and norms faced harsh punishment, often involving public flogging. For more serious transgressions — such as adultery — the practice of stoning was commonplace.
But almost two decades later, Taliban officials such Mujahid and Delawar, and spokesman Suhail Shaheen, are signaling that the group has softened its rough edges.
However, few Afghans are convinced, if the rush for seats on Western evacuation flights from Kabul airport is any indication. Fewer still are willing to speak openly about the issue, fearing reprisals.
“Everyone is waiting to see what will happen under the Taliban,” one Kabul resident told Arab News, speaking on condition of anonymity. “Women are going out of their homes now, but they are all wearing the hijab. Before it was different. Some wore it and others didn’t. Now they all wear it because they are afraid of the Taliban.”
Another Kabul-based woman, also speaking anonymously, said: “We don’t expect everything to be the same as it was before. There will be some change. We are waiting to see clarification on these policies issued by the Taliban.”
Ignoring their instincts, many Afghans want to believe that the Taliban will be better this time around. However, anecdotal reports of atrocities occurring across the country have kept the public on edge.
“There were rumors over the last week that single women outside Kabul have been taken and married off,” a spokesperson for one organization working in Afghanistan said on condition of anonymity.
“The key thing to remember is not that the Taliban is saying one thing and doing another necessarily. The Taliban is not one body yet.”
Indeed, a statement on Tuesday from a Taliban spokesman declared that women should stay at home for the time being because some of their fighters have “not yet been taught how to behave properly.”
Masuda Sultan, an Afghan-US entrepreneur and human rights advocate, said: “It is not clear if this applies to all women or women in some positions.
“Most women are not leaving their homes and are scared. People are being very careful. Recent news reports indicate the Taliban has recommended staying home for now. It’s like military rule now. They said women’s salaries would be paid but more training was needed for their own people.”
Women are not the only people in Afghanistan concerned about what happens next. Ethnic minorities, particularly the Hazara, a predominantly Shiite group concentrated in the country’s central mountainous region of Hazarajat, also faced persecution under the first Taliban regime.
Constituting 10 to 20 percent of the population, the Hazara were relegated to the bottom
rungs of the social order, which was topped by the Pashtun, an ethnicity from which the Taliban drew the bulk of its support.
Other ethnic groups — the Tajik, Uzbek, Turkmen, Baloch, Pashai, Nuristani, Gujjar, Arab, Brahui, Sadat, Kyrgyz and Pamiri peoples — are also unsure of where they stand.
The Hazara certainly have reason to be fearful again. After taking control of Ghazni province, Taliban militants killed nine Hazara men between July 4 and July 6 in the village of Mundarakht in Malistan district, according to human rights monitor Amnesty International.
Witnesses said that six of the men were shot and three were tortured to death. Human Rights Watch has urged the UN Human Rights Council to investigate similar reports of Taliban violence in the lead-up to the Aug. 15 fall of Kabul.
Afghans say that how the Taliban handles the rights of women and minorities will depend very much on the kind of government that takes shape as the group tightens its grip on power.
“Even though the Taliban have taken over most of the country, they haven’t actually formalized a political agreement. At the same time they face governance challenges,” said Sultan.
“We need and want to see good policies on women and girls. The Taliban have issued statements stating women and girls will have rights within Shariah law. Many people have been taking a waitand-see approach.”
When US forces conclude their scheduled withdrawal on Aug. 31, the sources of international aid and finance that kept the Afghan economy afloat since 2001 are expected to dry up.
Taliban leaders face the prospect of an economic implosion with serious humanitarian implications unless they can quickly broker new trade deals or non-Western powers throw them a lifeline.
According to UNHCR estimates, about 80 percent of the roughly 550,000 people internally displaced in recent weeks are women and children. Up to a third of Afghans were already considered food insecure at the start of 2021. Now the country is grappling with its second drought in three years.
UN agencies have warned of widespread food shortages across Afghanistan as early as September without urgent intervention.
“Afghanistan is in the middle of a humanitarian crisis,” Sultan said. “There are 18 million people in need of emergency aid. The World Food Program said that they cannot get food into the country because Kabul is currently closed to commercial flights.”
For the past several weeks, the international community has given its undivided attention to the evacuation effort and chaos at Kabul airport. Less attention has been paid to the far larger part of the population that is unable or unwilling to leave.
The Taliban could still build goodwill among the international donor community by not impeding the evacuation process and by matching their reassuring words with actions.
“The Taliban said that people can go back to work, but the dust hasn’t settled yet,” said Sultan. “Everyone is still waiting
to see what will happen.”
The key thing to keep in mind is that the Taliban is not one body yet.