Zero-rating VAT plan ‘is inadequate’
New value-added tax (VAT) exclusions have had no effect on the food baskets of struggling South African households, according to a civil society group.
New VAT exclusions have had no effect on the food baskets of struggling households, according to a civil society group.
Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity (PMBEJD), said on Wednesday the addition of cake flour to the list for zerorated goods resulted in a R2.16 saving on the food baskets of households living on low incomes. The group said its analysis showed that the total cost of the April 2019 household food basket was R3,076.76.
Zero-rating cake flour had not had any effect on the household affordability crisis, it said.
In 2018 the government increased the VAT rate to 15%. However, due to the public outcry on what this would mean for households living on low incomes, the Treasury appointed an independent panel of experts to investigate options to mitigate the increase’s effect.
The panel recommended zero rating white bread, bread flour and cake flour, sanitary pads, school uniforms and nappies. It further suggested that the national school nutrition programme be strengthened and the old age grant and child support grant be increased.
PMBEJD said most of the VAT panel recommendations were dismissed. In 2018, finance minister Tito Mboweni announced that as of April 1 2019, the government would zero-rate sanitary pads, bread flour and cake flour.
“No changes were made to the old age grant or the child support grant to mitigate the impact of the VAT rate increase. Shortly after minister Mboweni’s announcement, PMBEJD released a media statement arguing that removing VAT off a few food and nonfood items would not in itself be enough to mitigate the impact of the VAT increase on poorer households.”
The group said that zerorated foods themselves were not affordable and that households living on low incomes were highly exposed to VAT, with 20 out of the 38 foods that make up the typical food basket subject to VAT.
“It seemed to us that the Treasury’s response to mitigate the impact of VAT on poorer households by zero-rating a few more foods and nonfood items was not only based on several flawed assumptions on what people eat and how meals are put together but they had also missed the central point raised by civil society and trade unions [which is that] SA households are facing a massive food affordability crisis and require urgent government intervention.”
PMBEJD collected monthly food price data in April from six retail supermarkets which target the low-income market in Pietermaritzburg.
Out of the three items selected by the government for zero-rating, the group tracked cake flour and sanitary pads through its monthly household affordability index.
In March 2019 (before VAT exclusions came into force) the cost of 10kg cake flour on supermarket shelves was R75.82. In April 2019, after VAT exclusions were effected, the cost of 10kg cake flour on supermarket shelves was R73.66. The cost difference between March and April was R2.16.
“Zero-rating cake flour as an intervention to mitigate the impact of a rise in the VAT rate, as our data shows, has not been successful,” PMBEJD said.
“More importantly, however, is not the addition of cake flour to the zero-rating list, but government intervention in the totality of the household affordability crisis … zero-rating as a mitigation strategy is wholly inadequate because the savings to consumers are so marginal relative to the total cost of securing a household food basket.”