Coronavirus may be worse than reported
• Added ‘lung imaging’ test leads to numbers being adjusted
China’s official numbers of dead and infected from the coronavirus spiked dramatically on Thursday after authorities changed their counting methods, fuelling concern that the epidemic is far worse than reported.
China’s official numbers of dead and infected from the coronavirus spiked dramatically on Thursday after authorities changed their counting methods, fuelling concern the epidemic is far worse than reported.
Two top-ranking politicians overseeing the epicentre of the outbreak were also sacked, adding to questions over China’s handling of the crisis, just hours after President Xi Jinping claimed “positive results” in battling the outbreak.
The World Health Organisation (WHO) also quickly countered Chinese reassurances that the epidemic, which has now officially killed more than 1,350 people in China, would peak in a weeks. “I think it’s way too early to try to predict the beginning, the middle or the end of this epidemic right now,” said Michael Ryan, head of the WHO’s health emergencies programme.
The virus has had huge ramifications globally since emerging from the central Chinese province of Hubei in January, as many countries banned travellers from China in a bid to stop people spreading the disease.
In Hubei, where tens of millions of people are trapped as part of an unprecedented quarantine effort, 242 new deaths were reported on Thursday. Another 14,840 people were confirmed to be infected with the virus, with new cases and deaths by far the biggest one-day increases since the crisis began.
The jumps raised the death toll to 1,355 and the total number of nationwide infections of the virus — officially named Covid19 — to nearly 60,000.
Hubei authorities said the huge increase was because they had broadened their definition to include people “clinically diagnosed” via lung imaging. Until now, authorities had been documenting cases using a more sophisticated laboratory test.
The commission said it had looked into past suspected cases and revised diagnoses, suggesting older cases were included in Thursday’s numbers.
About 56-million people in Hubei and its capital, Wuhan, are being banned from leaving as part of the quarantine efforts. Tens of millions of others in cities far from the epicentre are also enduring travel restrictions.
China had been praised by the WHO for its transparent handling of the outbreak, in contrast to the way it concealed the extent of the SARS virus epidemic in 2002-2003. But it has faced continued scepticism from the global public, and US officials have also called for more openness from China’s Communist Party rulers, leading to fears that there may be similarities with the way it dealt with SARS.
Authorities in Hubei have been accused of concealing the gravity of the outbreak in late December and early January. The death of an infected doctor who had tried to raise the alarm about the outbreak then, but was silenced by authorities, triggered an outpouring of anger in China.
On Thursday, the leaders of Hubei and Wuhan were sacked, the highest-profile political scalps of the crisis. Hubei’s two top health officials had already been sacked this week.
Analysts said Hubei’s new methodology to count infections might be for medical reasons and could be because Xi wants officials to be more transparent, but the immediate effect was to sow more distrust.
“Oddly, this now is a moment of greater transparency,” Sam Crane, political science professor at Williams College in Massachusetts, said. “It is not clear if the problem up to now, on this issue, was lack of transparency or simply bad medical practice.”
Yun Jiang, a China researcher at Australian National University, said the new methodology may be a “practical measure” since Hubei has a shortage of laboratory testing kits. “I don’t think the numbers are necessarily manipulated for political purposes but the numbers themselves may not be so trustworthy.”
The biggest cluster of cases outside China is on a cruise ship quarantined off Japan’s coast, where 44 more people tested positive for Covid-19, raising the total number of infections on the Diamond Princes to 218.
Several countries have banned arrivals from China, while major airlines have halted flights to and from the country, as hundreds of people have now been infected in about two dozen countries. United Airlines has extended its China flight cancellations into late April.
The outbreak has wreaked havoc on global events, too.
In Spain, organisers of the world’s top mobile telecommunications trade fair, the World Mobile Congress, said the event would be cancelled after an exodus of industry heavyweights over coronavirus fears, including Ericsson, Nokia, Facebook, Amazon and Vodafone.
It has also disrupted sporting events in China: motorsport’s governing body FIA announced the suspension of the Formula One Grand Prix in Shanghai, originally scheduled for April 19, due to the “continued spread” of the coronavirus.
And this week’s Singapore Air Show — Asia’s biggest — was badly hit by exhibitors withdrawing and low attendance. US aircraftmaker Boeing has warned that there is “no question” the outbreak would hammer the aviation industry and the broader economy.
The epidemic has threatened to harm the Chinese economy, the world’s second-largest, with ANZ bank warning that China’s first-quarter GDP growth would slow to 3.2%-4.0%, down from a previous projection of 5.0%.
IT IS NOT CLEAR IF THE PROBLEM UP TO NOW, ON THIS ISSUE, WAS LACK OF TRANSPARENCY OR SIMPLY BAD MEDICAL PRACTICE
Getting ready: Florist Zhao Yuanyuan arranges flowers in her shop in Shanghai, China, ahead of Valentine’s Day. /