Safa boss satisfied with refs’ efforts
• Poor officiating hurting clubs, specially those at bottom of table
SA Football Association (Safa) head of referees Abdul Ebrahim has defended recent performances by Premier Soccer League (PSL) match officials but admits there is room for improvement.
Referees have been in the spotlight with some of their decisions questioned.
Another talking point on Monday night was a confusing officiating moment when Gabadinho Mhango’s late equaliser for Moroka Swallows against Mamelodi Sundowns was initially overruled then allowed.
There has been debate on whether Mhango was involved in play in the 2-2 draw when he was metres behind Sundowns’ last man to a long ball, and then, as referee Jelly Chavani ruled, was played onside by a misplaced header by Brazilians’ centreback Divine Lunga.
Downs coach Rulani Mokwena criticised the decision.
Former referee Ebrahim said officials were human beings who would continue to make mistakes.
“I am happy with the performances of all match officials; they make mistakes, but we deal with those mistakes. It doesn’t mean if someone makes a mistake, all of a sudden they are a poor person. It doesn’t mean if two referees make a mistake, refereeing is all of a sudden poor.
“Errors have been happening and our review committee deals with them. This is the norm every season — when something is wrong we try our best to fix it,” he said.
Last week, Cape Town Spurs coach Ernst Middendorp seemed to have a legitimate complaint when a decisive penalty was awarded against his team in a 1-0 defeat to Sundowns when the offending challenge occurred outside the box.
AmaZulu coach Pablo Franco Martin was incensed by an apparent soft penalty against his team in Usuthu’s 4-2 Nedbank Cup quarterfinal defeat against Orlando Pirates on Saturday.
Ebrahim, though, said that it was disappointing that the public often criticised officials because they did not fully understand Fifa rules.
“We are concerned but it doesn’t mean mistakes are happening regularly, but people are saying mistakes are happening. Sometimes when we [Safa’s review committee] analyse we get something different to what people are assuming.
“It is disappointing because the public in SA don’t know the laws of the game, how they are applied and how they should be understood.
“The first thing they jump to is the error, ‘the referee made a mistake and it cost us the game’,” said Ebrahim.
Match officiating in the Premier Soccer League (PSL) came into sharper focus on Monday night in the 2-2 draw between Moroka Swallows and Mamelodi Sundowns at Dobsonville Stadium.
The match, in which Sundowns blew a 2-0 lead, was dominated by a confusing officiating moment late in the second half after Swallows’ 85th-minute equaliser by Gabadinho Mhango.
Downs coach Rulani Mokwena said poor officiating was hurting clubs, specially those at the bottom of the table. He asked the SA Football Association (Safa), which controls refereeing, to look into the matter.
“I take the same stance as [Cape Town Spurs coach] Ernst Middendorp when he said you see a lot being done for the qualifications of coaches, who have to do this and that,” he said.
“I sometimes see, and it is unofficial [what Mokwena is told], but it breaks out even before the season starts. There are tests referees have to undergo and then you hear ‘Someone failed the test’.
“A few weeks later you see him [the same official] officiating a game, but you heard this guy failed a referees’ test.
“I don’t know if it’s the PSL or Safa but I think it’s Safa as custodians of football. Maybe they have to look at this situation. How many of our referees do international games and why are they not doing international games?”
Sundowns received coverage in the media for decisions seen as going their way in recent weeks, including the incident that drew comment from Middendorp, where a penalty was awarded from which Lucas Ribeiro scored the Brazilians’ winner when the challenge occurred outside the box.
There was also a goal disallowed for not crossing the line 100%, a decision upheld by VAR, in their Caf Champions League quarterfinal win against Young Africans, who lodged an official complaint with the Confederation of African Football.
“Let’s go to the Yanga situation. The VAR had to intervene on obvious situations and it said to the referee there is not sufficient evidence to suggest you have made a wrong call,” Mokwena said.
“Somebody who is sitting behind VAR needs to say to the referee: ‘Gabadinho Mhango was offside, he was a metre away from Divine Lunga’. Which defender is relaxed and composed when he has a striker in an offside position breathing down his neck?
“Maybe we don’t understand because we did not play professional football, but I am looking at this situation and I am saying, if I was in that situation, I would also be unsure of what’s happening.”
Mokwena said inconsistent officiating was damaging the reputation of SA football.
He said every week coaches complained about officials. AmaZulu coach Pablo Franco Martín complained about a contentious penalty decision in Usuthu’s defeat against Orlando Pirates on Saturday.
“I will speak because I have not spoken about referees the entire season and this time I will speak because it is very bad.”
There was debate about whether Mhango’s goal — initially overruled by referee Jelly Chavani and his team, but then allowed to stand — was legitimate. The striker was in a clear offside position by metres when the long ball was played, but arguably not involved in play, so not officially offside.
He would then have been played onside by Lunga’s backward header that allowed the Birds striker to run through and beat Ronwen Williams.
Sundowns travel to Tunisia for their huge Champions League semifinal first leg meeting against Esperance de Tunis on Saturday.
COACH SAYS POOR OFFICIATING IS HURTING CLUBS, SPECIALLY THOSE AT THE BOTTOM OF THE TABLE