Cape Times

Let’s not dwell on the ‘science’ and ‘facts’ behind medicine

- Deborah Ross

IF YOU ask me – and as the “scientific basis” for alternativ­e medical treatments is questioned yet again (the Bristol mother who tried to have her son’s brain tumour treated in an oxygen chamber; Prince Charles further endorsing homeopathy) – I feel it is time I showed my colours and spoke up on behalf of alternativ­e medicine and its practition­ers. You may even quiz me on this, if you like:

So, are you against convention­al science?

Not at all. It certainly has its place for, say, curing and preventing diseases, explaining our planet, saving our endangered species, tracing our evolution, extending all our lifespans and enhancing the quality of all our lives, but it has nothing to say, for example, about realigning your energy fields with ylang-ylang and as anyone who has realigned their energy fields with ylangylang will tell you: “My energy fields were all over the place previously, but now run as straight, smoothly and punctually as a Swiss train.”

Having researched the scientific lit- erature in depth, I can tell you with confidence that convention­al medicine has done nothing when it comes to energy fields running like Swiss trains, and has nothing to say about it.

Nothing. Not even one research paper. Pathetic.

What is the principle behind homeopathy?

Homoeopath­s treat the sick with extremely diluted agents, sometimes so diluted that the water only has a “memory” of the “curative powers” of the original agent.

Does this mean I can pay a home- opath with the fluff from my pocket, which, surely, would “remember” it had rubbed up against money at some point? Yes. Of course. It would make just as much sense, although do remember this: if the homeopath refuses the fluff, turfs you out of his office, or sends you invoice after invoice before putting the bailiffs on to you, it is only because a homeopath’s brain “remembers” that cash is nice and, as a rule, more acceptable should you wish to purchase, say, a latté from Starbucks or curtains from John Lewis. This, I’m afraid, is a sad indictment of the world we live in today, which cannot accept fluff for the memories it might hold. Such a pity.

Some people say that, rather than consult an alternativ­e therapist, you may as well consult a cat. What do you think of this? I would laugh in their faces. When it comes down to it, isn’t laughter the best medicine? Yes. Though I’m forced to admit that when it comes to erectile dysfunctio­n, the jury is still rather out.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa