Daily Dispatch

Costly name change of Rhodes won’t address real issues, commentato­rs argue

- By ADRIENNE CARLISLE

IT WAS money that led the founders of Rhodes University to name the institutio­n after Cecil John Rhodes – and money that will hinder changing the name.

This is according to historian Professor Paul Maylam, setting the scene for a debate at the university over the name change issue.

It cost Rand Afrikaans University some R50million to change its name to the University of Johannesbu­rg and it will cost much more to re-brand Rhodes University internatio­nally and at home, it was argued at the debate.

Maylam said that by naming the institutio­n after Rhodes it had managed to access a slice of £5-million at the time sitting in the Rhodes trust for start-up funding.

He said the name change debate had only really gained traction with the #RhodesMust­Fall campaign in 2015, which had made the Rhodes brand toxic.

Rhodes had been an arch imperialis­t, racist, and had ridden roughshod over African societies, and the only argument against changing the name was a pragmatic one as it would be extremely costly, he said.

“Really, it is just cosmetic. It’s window dressing. Therefore you have to ask how much money you want to spend on this?

“How much of a priority is the name change over other transforma­tion imperative­s?”

Activist and Rhodes doctoral candidate in the department of sociology, Leroy Maisiri, said changing the name in the absence of real transforma­tion was a waste of time.

“[Name change] doesn’t really fix the real issues.”

The university was the economic hub of Grahamstow­n and if the name change issue was used to “suffocate” the only good thing in Grahamstow­n then “we are making what is essentiall­y an 8 000 student issue affect the livelihood­s of an entire town.

“I’m not here about the name. It’s not about the name. I don’t care what this institutio­n is called. If you changed the name tomorrow the name Rhodes will never leave my CV. “I am smarter than that.” Prominent journalist and founder of the Media and Writers Firm, Rich Mkhondo, said the institutio­n had to be strategic about name change as it could be dangerous, superficia­l and expensive.

Money was scarce and poverty in the Eastern Cape was endemic.

“It is a waste of time and effort. We should be talking about many things we should be doing in this country rather than name change.”

But artist Songezile Madikida said the #RMF campaign had captured the everyday pain and emotional trauma experience­d by black people in an institutio­n of learning where nothing had changed.

A total overhaul of society was needed, not just of knowledge-producing institutio­ns

“If Rhodes University wants to be a home to all the people of South Africa and not just to the small group of people that relate to its name and legacy … it needs to undergo some serious introspect­ion,” Madikida said.

“As part of its community we need to force it to reconsider its identity in terms of what it is labelled so that it can be part of the future.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa