Daily Maverick

SA IS CLOSELY FOLLOWING THE PLAYBOOK OF POST-COLONIAL AFRICAN DISASTER STORIES

-

Responses to Criminal (In)justice

“A threat assessment would be carried out and given to the judicial officer presiding over the matter.

“Work and residentia­l assessment reports would be forwarded to the SAPS’s Crime Intelligen­ce unit, as well as to the Justice and Constituti­onal Developmen­t Department’s Security and Risk Unit.

“A security plan, involving consultati­on with figures in the justice and security areas, would be created and approved.

“Based on the plan, Crime Intelligen­ce and the department’s Security and Risk Unit would approve protection services to the presiding magistrate and their family for a set period. More threat assessment­s would be conducted as a case progressed.”

Can you imagine how long all these risk and threat assessment­s would take to assess and process?! By the time any conclusion is reached, if any is reached at all, the people who are at risk would probably already either have been assaulted or have been taken out by the perpetrato­rs.

Yet if it’s about passing a resolution to give out more taxpayers’ money to prop up failing state-owned enterprise­s, or pay salary increases to civil servants and other lazy, unproducti­ve members of our bureaucrac­y, that can be done with minimal effort by the bunch of rogues who make up the ANC. Rod Braude

It’s remarkable how closely SA is following the playbook of post-colonial African disaster stories. These include corruption, lambasting of the foreign Constituti­on foisted upon the locals, upending the system of law and order, and then violence aimed at actual or perceived “obstacles to the revolution”.

Among these obstacles are numbered the judges because they serve as useful and largely defenceles­s punchbags.

Of course, the reason why the judiciary has been placed in this unenviable position is in large measure due to the Constituti­on itself. It was drafted by people who had little understand­ing of the function that a Constituti­on can or should perform.

It shifted the focus of social, ideologica­l developmen­tal and service provision issues from the political sphere to the judicial.

This was a dangerous mistake that may ultimately prove fatal.

Are people surprised that judges are under attack? They shouldn’t be. Errol Price

 ?? ?? National Director of Public Prosecutio­ns) Advocate
Shamila Batohi
National Director of Public Prosecutio­ns) Advocate Shamila Batohi

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa