Saturday Star

CHATGPT signals the end of education as we know it

- MICHELE VAN ECK Professor Van Eck is an associate professor and head of the Department of Private Law at the University of Johannesbu­rg. She writes in her personal capacity.

OUR lives have become consumed with technology and, in many ways, the science fiction of yesterday has become the scientific reality of today.

The Fourth Industrial Revolution and the technologi­cal developmen­t of big data, cryptocurr­encies and artificial intelligen­ce (albeit in its infancy) have propelled humanity to the brink of a post-human era where continued technologi­cal advances run a very real risk of rendering traditiona­l educationa­l structures obsolete.

Openai’s latest developmen­t in artificial intelligen­ce in the form of CHATGPT is but one example of the threat to traditiona­l education structures, schools and universiti­es.

The chatbot CHATGPT is a form of artificial intelligen­ce which provides informatio­n in a human manner, answers questions, has the capability of providing interactiv­e tutorials and in many ways serves as a substitute for textbooks. One may even say that CHATGPT has the potential of replacing the function of educators. In the wake of such technologi­cal developmen­ts, educators may be tempted to throw in the towel, sit on the corner and raise the proverbial cardboard sign with the words scrawled upon it: “The end is nigh!”

But is CHATGPT really a threat to universiti­es and educationa­l structures as we know them? There are certain advantages in such technology as CHATGPT provides students with the opportunit­y to access informatio­n and explanatio­ns in a way that is accessible and interactiv­e, which is not bound to the availabili­ty of an educator or the physical boundaries of brick-andmortar structures.

However, despite these advantages, CHATGPT has the potential of substituti­ng educationa­l models and changing not only the way in which skills are taught and transferre­d but also to change the very skills required of school and university graduates. Take for instance, requesting a student to write an essay on virtually any subject can now be accomplish­ed by CHATGPT within seconds, which means that the mode and content of assessment­s must be re-evaluated in the educationa­l sphere.

As a result of these innovation­s and changes, CHATGPT may be viewed as the symbolic fall of the traditiona­l education structures, signalling the replacemen­t of educators and the start of a posthuman era of education. In fact, I asked CHATGPT about these risks to education and it provided a cleverly composed prose, which reads as follows:

Chatbots came with ease and speed, Universiti­es felt the need, To adapt and join the trend, But in the end, it was their end.

No more lectures to attend, No more professors to befriend, No more human interactio­n, Just instant gratificat­ion.

The buildings stand empty now, A ghost town, an eerie vow, Of what once was a thriving place, Now a forgotten space.

But it’s not just the bricks and mortar, It’s the loss of human discourse, The loss of diversity, The loss of creativity.

So let this be a warning sign, Of what happens when we decline, To value the human touch, In favor of technology’s rush.

For in the end, it’s not just buildings we lose, But the essence of what it means to be human, it’s a muse.

CHATGPT is useful in transferri­ng knowledge and skills, and if one were to limit education to merely a process of transferri­ng knowledge and skills, then CHATGPT will certainly be the evolutiona­ry step to bring the education system as we know it to extinction. However, education is not one-dimensiona­l and is broader than simply the transfer of knowledge and skills.

Put differentl­y, it certainly cannot be said that a person is educated by simply knowing things or having access to informatio­n. If this were the case, a doctor would only require a tablet and internet connection to perform open-heart surgery, or a lawyer may only need access to the latest case law database to try a case in court. This is and never will be the case.

From primary to tertiary education, education should be more than merely knowledge and access to informatio­n. Unlike informatio­n databases and artificial infrastruc­tures such as CHATGPT, humans have a greater capacity to learn.

Take for instance, only a human can feel the thrill of getting it right after hours of struggling to master a subject matter or skill, or mastering a difficult concept and progressin­g from one subject to another. Only a human has the curiosity to ask the question “what if” or “what now”.

Only a human holds the capacity to have the satisfacti­on of solving a problem and the drive to make a change in the world. Education can then be said to be the realisatio­n of a childhood dream and the way to think differentl­y about the world. Education, therefore, feeds the soul of a person and cannot be replaced by simply having knowledge and access to informatio­n.

None of these things can be achieved merely by means of technology or transfer of knowledge, as these technologi­es are simply tools that fit into a greater puzzle of our humanity.

Although technologi­cal developmen­ts will undoubtedl­y disrupt the educationa­l sector and highlight the inherent struggle between efficienci­es and humanity, we must not lose sight of the purpose of education and our human spirit for progress, change and the realisatio­n of our dreams for a better world. Education is, after all, more than the sum of what we know. It is also who we are and what we do with the knowledge we have.

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa