Make Your Point

THE DEADLINE FOR NEXT WEEK’S ‘MAKE YOUR POINT’ IS MONDAY, 10AM. Please note that letters / emails of more than 200 words will not be considered for publication.

WELL-DONE KA BO YELLOW

Mamelodi Sundowns, almost every year, put Mzansi on the map of football and whether you support them or not, they will represent in USA next year. I’m not a fan of the Yellow Nation, but wow, they are the only team that takes their fans seriously in the PSL by keeping them happy. Welldone Yellow Nation.

Kagoentle Pitse, via e-mail

Rhulani Mokwena simply just chokes and overthinks in big games. He lost the CAF Champions League semis in the first leg when it was 50/50. In the first leg, Esperance played an open game and only defended in the latter stages of the game. Shalulile deserved to start the first leg despite his goal drought. His work rate and ability to convert chances was enough for him to start ahead of Lorch. In the second leg it made sense for Esperance to defend playing away. But how do you start Maseko and even replace him with Morena against a reinforced defence? A football person knows that in that game one or two of Zwane or Sirino or Mabena should have started to unlock a reinforced defence.

Nkosinathi Mkhwanazi, via e-mail

Congratulations to Mamelodi Sundowns FC for a great and successful 2023/2024 season. Winning the AFL ($75 million), DStv Premiership (R15 million), reaching the CAF Champions League semi-finals ($1.2 million), being runners-up of the MTN8, qualifying for the FIFA Club World Cup which comes with a whopping R1 billion, is truly amazing. Big up to the team, I’m really proud of Mamelodi Sundowns, from the management, board, technical team, players, supporters. Wow, I can’t ask for more. I can’t fault anyone for bowing out of the CAF Champions League semi-final, the boys gave it all. It was there for everyone to see that luck was not on our side, but the boys did very well, super proud of them. Our PSL was against Sundowns, how could they make them play three games in a space of seven days? That includes travelling across the continent, but God loves us all. I am 100% behind coach Rhulani, and so wish that he could rest players who had been playing throughout the season and give the fringe players an opportunity. He has nothing to lose, even if he doesn’t win the Nedbank Cup it’s ok, we have already achieved more than too much this season. Ka Bo Yellow Masandawana. Barnes Hadebe, Sundowns Estcourt Branch

The fatal mistake committed was to think that Sundowns is an experimental team where you can chop and change the team at will. Favouritism played a huge role in Sundowns’ elimination from the Champions League. The best teams in the world, such as Real Madrid and Man City, do not temper with a winning combination. Sirino could have easily won that game for Sundowns, but Aubaas and Roberto failed to deliver.

Thabo Mabetoa, Pretoria

Let me take this opportunity to give credit to Sundowns for their efforts in the CAF Champions League semi-finals. In the words of Wilma Rudolph: “Winning is great, sure, but if you are really going to do something in life, the secret is learning how to lose”. After the success in the AFL, it is very clear most teams would want to beat Sundowns in order to prove a point. Truth be told, fatigue knocked Sundowns as most players did not have the energy required to win the CCL. You have no choice about how you lose, but you do about how you can come back and prepare to win again. There’s no time for self-pity or doubting our abilities. Now is the time for the Club Board, Technical Team, Players and Supporters to look at the bigger picture instead of crying over spilt milk. We shall overcome the temporary incompetence of losing in the semi-finals. Coach Rhulani will grow from the experience of losing in semi-finals twice in a row. My advice is, in football there is always a need for the element of surprise against opponents. It is time for coach Rhulani to reignite or re-energize the team by allowing players who did not enjoy game-time to carry our team going forward, starting with the Nedbank Cup and the last few league games. Let’s start planning for the FIFA Club World Cup Championship in the USA. Yellow and resolute we remain.

Patrick Jomo Pilane, Sebokeng

The sun went down on the Brazilians at a thunderstorm-threatened Loftus Versfeld Stadium on Friday night. It was a matter of so close, yet so far for Downs to bow out in successive Champions League semi-finals. The hosts were quick to settle and forced the visitors into their own half. It was no surprise to see that the visitors had zero shots on goal in the entire first half. Williams had no saves to make, he was just a mere spectator. Esperance came with a game plan to allow Sundowns to have the ball and play with a low-block and try to catch them on the counter-attacks. In an attempt to look for an early goal in the second half, Sundowns pushed more bodies up front and the visitors exploited the space at the back and caught Downs on the counter to score. After the goal it was a mountain to climb for the hosts to score three goals to advance. The opposition keeper stood his ground and made world-class saves to keep his team in the game. Can it be that Rhulani’s starting line-up cost him dearly as he put an experienced, influential Zwane on the bench. Hard luck, Masandawana, better luck next time. At least the team qualified for the FIFA Club World Cup.

Gavin Ryan, Emalahleni

I am a soccer-loving fan and also a Kaizer Chiefs supporter, but I am disappointed about Sundowns’ defeat. I thought they would go through to the final and put Mzansi on the map. Hard luck Masandawana, next time you will do better. You did your best, but luck was not on your side this time around. I salute you Ka Bo Yellow. Nghamula Rikhotso, Nkonwana, Mageva Village

Although we are disheartened by the painful exit of Sundowns from the CAF tournament, we have something positive to celebrate and take pride in regarding the Brazilians. The troops surrendered on the battlefield. This is extraordinary heroism. Esperance came with defensive tactics, but the Brazilians played better. They were so unfortunate to lose the match, given the numerous scoring chances they created. Despite the sensational exit, we still applaud them for their heroic campaign this this season. Sundowns have been representing the Southern African region extremely well recently. The brilliance of the Brazilians has made the sub- Saharan region address the issue of playing second fiddle to North and West Africa in terms of continental football dominance. Let us applaud the Sundowns head coach Rhulani Mokwena, senior coach Manqoba Mngqithi and the entire technical team for taking Sundowns to greater heights in recent times. After having two consecutive CAF semi-final exits, Sundowns may be considered as “mere Bridesmaids” of the African football. But we see them becoming the Bride of the African football in not far future. The boys only need unconditional support in the quest for the second CAF star.

Batsirai Kativu, Johannesburg

A lot has been said about Mamelodi Sundowns. In South Africa they are not heroes but in Africa they are heroes and among the best internationally. People were bored about how the team advanced in the CAF Champions League. They believed that Sundowns is wasting their time on finishing the league early. Some couldn’t hide their support of the visiting team against Mamelodi Sundowns. Coach Rhulani and his technical team must travel all around looking for the best striker to redeem Shalulile. Again, they played really well but failed to convert their chances. I’m happy they are the only team that play for the country, for our football. The country is supposed to be proud of Mamelodi Sundowns. Now that they qualified to play in FIFA Club World Cup, the country is supposed to be proud of participating. Congratulations coach Rhulani, the technical team, players, Motsepe family, supporters, sponsors for taking the institution to higher levels. Now the world will witness the best of South African football because of you. To Masandawana supporters: Yellow Nation must not be distracted by those who don’t know who they support. Let us not frustrate our progress and start blaming the coach and the boys. Let’s rally behind them and support the team through thick and thin.

Terah Maqepula, Mount Fletcher, Eastern Cape

A very difficult second leg for Sundowns. Esperance is one of the teams which can defend well and score. Their plan works well, they knew very well that Downs will take the game to them, and they would catch them on the counter. Sundowns were cruising but their finishing was their weak point. And it’s strange for Sundowns to struggle on that aspect. Their dominance didn’t trouble Esperance, Sundowns played many long balls and that is where they dominated aerially. Sundowns played to the gallery, and they didn’t have plan B to overcome their counterpart. Shalulile was the main culprit because he missed a lot of chances. If I was the coach, I would have never sacrificed Zwane for Maseko because Zwane can give you what you want as a coach. The Sundowns back four was shaky and the goal that was scored by Esperance was from bad defending. Coetzee and Aubaas did not combine, while Allende was inspiring with his fighting spirit – he tried his best. It was Sundowns’ chance to redeem themselves but they failed dismally. Their loss will affect them, it was so disappointing to see Sundowns lose in that fashion. The dream of our country was shattered.

Madimetja Vic Mashamaite, Renstown

AMAKHOSI AJABULILE

It’s been so long since we had a feel of what a victory tastes like. I don’t credit anyone for this victory, not the players, not management, not even the coach. This one is for the universe or football gods feeling for us against our struggling hoodoo team. I can’t and won’t compliment a lion for its hunting skills for it will starve failure to catch prey. I don’t feel for the coach one bit. If he’s not consistent with his Hlanti’s selection, he is so hellbent on playing Kwinika at any given chance. Strangely, he doesn’t play Frosler, who is actually better than both of them combined. Frosler was even involved in the second goal after coming on as a substitute. The only thing that we’re left with this season is to break Sundowns’ hearts today because a Top Eight finish is non-negotiable. No amount of medication could heal Mngqithi’s chest pains when Chiefs handed them their only defeat a couple of seasons ago. Only if Chiefs players knew how much it would mean if they did that for us. It’s mostly new Sundowns supporters, who don’t appreciate their team efforts, and want microwave Champion League success and get their hearts broken over one loss. On the other hand, if Sundowns beat us it won’t hurt much considering that they haven’t lost in the league. We have been hurt enough over the years and a victory against them will be so sweet. Everyone wants a piece of us.

“Kanu” Vilakazi wanted to beat us, and only to lose his next game against a rockbottom team, Cape Town Spurs.

Lucky Khunou, Rustenburg, Meriting

At least our team Kaizer Chiefs put smile on our faces this past weekend by beating SuperSport United by two goals to one. Next one is the tired Sundowns; we have to take advantage of that and put more salt in their wounds for losing against Esperance in the semifinal of the CAF Champions League. Thanks to AmaZulu for bringing Chippa United down to mother earth because they were starting to think that they were untouchable.

Nyambeni Samson Khuphani, Tshiawelo Ext 5

Kaizer Chiefs have become notorious for allowing the hypetobuildupwhenit comes to seeking out a new coach, only for them to pull out someone from under a rock. We were all anxious and kept in suspense not so long ago, only for them to appoint Arthur Zwane. At the end of Zwane’s tenure, again the anticipation was heightened as we expected a big name to come to the rescue, and once again, Chiefs lifted that same old rock to unleash Ntseki. The same model that Chiefs employs when it comes to signing free reject players will be applied towards their coach. I write to remind the supporters not to expect too much. This is Chiefs and they remain unmatched when it comes to disappointing their supporters and they will do it again. Lower your expectations, Makhosi.

Ray, Durban

FIVE-STAR STELLIES

South Africa, brace yourselves, there is a new gang that is terrorising what is supposedly a friendly and heartwarming space into a volatile and belligerent atmosphere. When Stellenbosch first came into the elite league, there was noise about who the owners were but there was nothing to show for it. And we were left wondering what was the intention of these people in our football because we thought they were going to compete in the transfer market? Instead, we saw the usual suspects pouncing on their gems. Little did we know that they are affording a platform for the unknown young boys from their own province. This is very encouraging to see when clubs invest on young local talent and affording our coaches an opportunity to work in an environment that has the necessary resources and less pressure to produce results. They already have the Carling Knockout in the bag and look set to qualify for the CAF Champions League and might pull a surprise in the Nedbank Cup semifinal against Sundowns. I’m actually tempted to put my head on the block and vouch for a Stellies v Pirates final. If they, together with Pirates, start next season in the same form, then we are in for a bumper 2024/25 season.

Zola Bashin Kati, Zwelitsha

Give that man his flowers while he can still smell them. Rayners scoring five goals and sitting on top of the charts is something to marvel. He is really enjoying his time at Stellies. And oh, that team from Naturena have managed to work their way back to the Top Eight. Hunt starting with six young players from their development team and one of his subs was also a young man from the development caught my eye. It’s disturbing why Chiefs are keeping their young talent on the bench and even in the stands. Vila came in, in Mdu’s place. Why don’t youfieldthematthesame time and bring in that energy even Mangethe is rotting on thebench.

Siyabonga Nkalambela, Delft

READERS’ RESPONSE

In the Editor’s Column of the last issue, I totally agree with VeeJay that the boys are denied an opportunity to enjoy their football. Having said that, I don’t really know what the editor expects Chiefs to do unless you know what the problems are. From where I stand as a Khosi supporter, I believe the management has signed well this season and surely the players are well-taken care of. We can point some fingers at the management, but players need to come to the party for the team and their respective careers. I always say players are more responsible for results than anyone at the club because they are the ones playing.

Malesela “Dance” Boya, Kanana, Hammanskraal

Since l fell in love with the Beautiful Game, l got to know many people. But I’m shattered to learn that a wellknown person, someone in football would want to take the life of Alpheus Thantsha because of football and accusing him of sleeping with players. If there is any truth to the story sa ka (of) Mr Thantsha in Soccer Laduma edition 1371, it must stop. Dr Nelson Mandela once said

that sports can unite people, not to kill them. Emmang (stop).

Joshua Makaung Potsiso, Mamone Ga-Mmela village

Quick One-Two’s

29-year-old German footballer Robert Andrich scored in the 96th minute against Stuttgart to salvage a point for champions Leverkusen. Coach Alonso’s side have now won or equalised in stoppage time 10 times this season in all competitions. They are showing a remarkable fighting spirit in their pursuit to become the only German team to go the whole season undefeated. The saying that it is never over till the Fat Lady sings really applies perfectly for this Bundesliga side and I am rooting for them to go far in the Europa league and lift it.

Amos “Tiger” Tshukudu, Ga-Maria

The English Premier League has reached boiling point. It is still a three-horse race. Arsenal are refusing to stop fighting for the title, they are fighting to the bitter end. It is not easy in the EPL, Manchester City are keeping Arsenal on their toes. It’s tough, but I still say: “It is like a movie that we have seen before”. Manchester City will win the title, meanwhile I pray for Burnley FC not to be relegated.

Moses Mokoena, Ga-Mokwakwaila

Suffering humiliation and working hard is the way to go to the top. I remember vividly, ‘Teabag’ was booed by everyone, and he once cried, but still looked ahead. After the storm the birds sing. Ngezana won the league, wow, what a moment for him. God has his own timing. ‘Teabag’ is an example of those who go through tough times, hail the champion of the Romanian League. Soccer Laduma staff and editor, your work is amazing, shower us with great news. Keep it up. To both teams that are going to the finals of the Champions League, big up. Let me vote now for ‘Tito’ Maswanganyi, Player of the Season.

Danny “Madeenzo” Moreo, Segakwana Village, Moruleng

What an incredible performance by Pirates against Royal AM. What I like from their side, they play to win and score many goals as they can, and it will help them at the end of the season. Wow, well done to Amakhosi for their win against SuperSport United. Teamwork leads to positive results. I wish them all the best for the remaining games, although it is not going to be easy. The English Premier League is getting interesting now, the race is on. I’m looking forward to Man City’s next game. If they win, Arsenal will drop down. DStv Premiership players need to learn from English Premier League players, on how to play positive football while scoring goals and entertaining followers. Bring VAR here in South Africa to reduce unfair practices by our officials.

Isaac Tsenene, via email

Orbit College let the people of Rustenburg and the whole North West province down. They started like a house on fire and only to slip up in the dying minutes. They should strategize, ensure that they always get maximum points at home with the support they were getting from their 12th man (supporters) at their home games and fight for a point playing away. I still recall how my colleague Raymond Mika convinced and even offered to buy me a ticket to go along to watch their home game against Baroka, which the latter won 1-0. The very same day Kaizer Chiefs were playing against Orlando Pirates, and you could have seen that the guy had traded his love for Amakhosi for Orbit College. The stadium was filled to capacity and I even wrote in MYP about their young defender wearing No. 23 (Thabang Nhlapo) whose style of play is similar to that of OJ Mabizela. One million-dollar question now is: “What went wrong?” Just like in Bloemfontein, people of Rustenburg are starved of professional football, living a few miles away from the Olympia Stadium. I always witness people who go there in large numbers to watch the team play, but I still insist that they should get them a talkative and well-known spokesperson to market their home games in the surrounding areas. They must also use Soccer Laduma to inform people of exactly where and when the team is playing. It was always reported in this lovely “Thursday Soccer Bible” that the team will be playing at Royal Bafokeng Stadium, only to find that the correct venue is Olympia. But I must also confess that it’s not a train smash considering that it’s their maiden season. People of Rustenburg, don’t despair, get more involved next season. Play your part like you were always doing throughout this season and hope for the best. I urge even Tuks management to think of staging some of their home games at Olympia Stadium next season if they do get automatic promotion, although I still wish for Magesi to be promoted as a Limpopian myself. Limpopo talent is immeasurable and it’s good for the province to have more teams competing in the elite league. I wish one of them would think of registering Mahwelereng Stadium as an alternative home ground for the sake of the people of Mokopane and rope the likes of seasoned administrator Ria Ledwaba in.

Tente “The Brains” Mokoka, Sepharane

Today I want to ask you if you think Real Madrid won the UCL quarterfinal against Manchester City by luck, and if you think Esperance won their CAF Champions League semifinal by chance? To put things into perspective, we know that Manchester City is a top club with good football and are current holders of the same UCL, all inspired by the reputable football manager in Pep Guardiola. If you asked me what I thought the results of the two ties were going to be I would have told you I don’t know about the score lines and who will win where (as they play home and away), but I knew Madrid would go through. And coming back to our African shores I had the same feeling about Sundowns vs Esperance. As for me I have seen Sundowns beating these successful North

African clubs especially in group stages, but have you noticed that the same clubs would go on to win the Champions League when Sundowns only goes as far as semi-finals? We might say we are beating these North African teams and with bigger score lines if you want to claim that but around the same periods of time, we don’t get to Champions League finals and they are always there, how so if it’s the same teams we beat in the same competition? Only watching football will answer that and remember to watch the right football, not hockey or NFL. Al Ahly is not 13-time African champions by Sundowns or Pirates mercy, they put in the work, and they know when not to lose a football match in these competitions. No wonder they make it to the finals almost every year. When was the last time we had a South African team in a CAF final? I think it was Chiefs some three years ago, where they got beaten 3-0 by Al Ahly.

(Ed’s note: Pirates against RS Berkane in the Confed Cup in May 2022).

CAF Confederation Cup or Champions League have been won once by a South African club over the last 10 years and too many times by the North African teams. Due to this football heritage it’s not easy for a Manchester City to progress to UCL semis or finals via Madrid no matter how good they are. But remember the Bernabeu club is not 14-time UCL champions by fluke, these clubs know exactly what it takes to play such competitions especially during knockout stages, there is a football heritage and it takes a lot of work to overturn these odds. Sundowns winning the league and Chiefs fighting for a Top Eight finish is something that will continue for the next three years at least with Pirates as the bridesmaids during that period, says this football heritage not me. If you ask me, Borussia Dortmund have slightly better chances of winning the Champions League than PSG, besides stars at the French Club but football heritage odds favour the Signal Idunabased club over PSG. You can use such odds in so many ways but throw your heart out of the window, dear reader, to see facts.

Kwazikwakhe “Mapholoba” Ngcobo, Umlazi