Mandela fraud accused hit with forfeiture order
State seizes R1.38m, plus interest, from businessman
About R1.38m, plus interest, of businessman Dean Fanoe’s funds have been forfeited to the state as ill-gotten gains from his role in the Nelson Mandela memorial service scandal.
Judge Sunil Rugunanan ruled that Fanoe and his close corporation Mantella Trading had benefited directly from the proceeds of unlawful activities and ordered that R1.38m and all the interest it had accumulated over the intervening seven years should immediately be forfeited to the state.
Fanoe made R692,000 profit on an ANC T-shirt deal as a procurement middleman.
His cut of about R1.38m was part of the roughly R10m the state says in court papers was fraudulently diverted from the Buffalo City Metro (BCM) budget meant for former president Mandela’s funeral.
According to court papers, Fanoe – a close friend of then
ANC regional secretary Pumlani Mkolo – was given his R1.38m slice of the pie but paid the actual T-shirt supplier only R688,000.
When the scandal broke in 2014, the Asset Forfeiture Unit (AFU) moved in and obtained a preservation order freezing R5m in various bank accounts, including the R1.38m in Fanoe’s business account.
Some time later, the R1.38m
was forfeited to the state as being proceeds of a crime.
But, shortly afterwards, the National Prosecuting Authority temporarily withdrew criminal charges against Mkolo, Fanoe and nine others allegedly implicated in the fraud scandal. Fanoe immediately went to court to get back his funds.
Judge John Smith in March last year rescinded the forfeiture order and ordered that the money remain frozen in the AFU’s lawyers’ trust account.
Fanoe claimed in court papers there was no evidence the payment of the amount of R1.38m was the instrumentality or the proceeds of a criminal offence committed by himself or Mantella Trading 522.
He said his dealings had been with Victory Ticket and its director and taxi boss Mzwandile Sokwali (also known as Richard Ntozini) as part of a normal business transaction.
But, the state also produced Sokwali’s affidavit in which he pleaded guilty to fraud and money-laundering.
The taxi businessman said Mkolo had asked him, through his company Victory Ticket, to inflate a quote for BCM for transporting mourners from R6m to R10m as they would need the R4m balance to finance “other ANC activities”.
Victory Ticket was only registered on the Buffalo City Metro database after rendering and being paid for the services. Victory Ticket also paid other service providers, including Fanoe.
Fanoe acknowledges in his affidavit that he is a close friend of Mkolo. He also claimed that the 100% mark-up on the T-shirts was a “norm in the industry”.
But Rugunanan said no proper procurement process had been followed to appoint Victory Ticket as a service provider and all the services had been rendered before the municipal manager had even approved any deviation from normal processes.
He said it was clear from the evidence that Mkolo handpicked Fanoe to provide Tshirts and Victory Ticket had been used as a “conduit for laundering BCM funds” into various bank accounts.
“Fanoe benefited directly from the proceeds of unlawful activities.”
‘‘ Direct benefit from proceeds of unlawful activities