The Citizen (Gauteng)

Number of seats the EFF garnered following last week’s national election

- – simnikiweh@citizen.co.za

needing the EFF to enact EWC and the other “highly probable” scenario, in which an amendment is successful­ly challenged in the Constituti­onal Court.

“What the smaller parties can do, or any interest group that don’t like the idea, is go to the Constituti­onal Court and say, we don’t need a two-thirds majority, we need a 75% majority,” he said.

“This view has been expressed by some lobby groups, based on the fact that the constituti­on says that a fundamenta­l right can only be taken away by a 75% majority in parliament, and there is a high probabilit­y that this case could land up in the Constituti­onal Court.”

Friedman added that even in the case where a two-thirds majority was deemed enough to amend section 25, the ANC and EFF may not be on the same page when it comes to how this legislatio­n would be interprete­d. In fact, he said, the ANC didn’t share the EFF’s hunger for expropriat­ion without compensati­on.

The EFF has repeatedly gone on record stating that government should be the custodian of land, a far more extreme approach than proposed by the ANC.

Former public protector Thuli Madonsela argued recently at a women only conference on land – comprising of law experts from around the country – that it was possible for parliament­arians to agree to an amendment of section 25 which did not violate property rights.

“It depends on what is contained in the clause and the nature of the amendment,” she said.

“If the amendment simply clarifies the circumstan­ces under which land may be expropriat­ed without compensati­on, that on its own would not necessaril­y translate to a violation of the constituti­on.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa