Beggars distract us from true poverty
● ‘Professional drifters’ at traffic intersections only make up tiny percentage of the poor in SA
Many traffic intersections in South African cities are occupied by beggars and peddlers of wares who pursue a captive audience when the lights turn red.
The definition of “harassment” involves a person not being able to escape unwanted demands or threats – and demanding a driver’s attention while he is trapped at a traffic light falls under this definition.
Few people seem to be aware that it is illegal to loiter at traffic intersections.
The National Road Traffic Act (“Duties of Pedestrians”) states that, “A pedestrian shall not walk on a roadway except for the purpose of crossing from one side to the other or for some other sufficient reason”.
There seems to be a perception in SA that begging and selling goods constitutes a “sufficient reason” to be there, and the perception is reinforced by a lack of will from the police and traffic officers to remove the offenders.
The Act emphasises that “no pedestrian on a public road shall conduct himself or herself in such a manner as to constitute a source of danger to himself or herself or to other traffic” and that “a pedestrian, when crossing a public road on a pedestrian crossing or in any other manner, shall not linger but shall proceed with due dispatch”.
I have yet to see a hint of “due dispatch” in any of the artful dodgers who conduct their business at intersections.
It is unpleasant to be approached by sullen-looking beggars holding bags, asking for rubbish and pleading for money if one doesn’t have any rubbish to put in their bags.
Beggars and sellers of wares make people feel unsafe at traffic lights, particularly at night.
Why should a person have to wind up her window and keep an eye on her rear view mirror to make sure that the guy wandering around her car isn’t going to break her window and grab her bag?
Why should a motorist be held up and miss his chance to go through the green lights just because the driver in the car ahead of him is too busy buying coat hangers from a vendor or fiddling around for spare change in his wallet?
The illegal activity at intersections has become one of the so-called “little” misdemeanours that law enforcement officials and the public turn a blind eye to.
Because of the lack of jobs and a general disregard for law and order, those who are seen to be disadvantaged, are pitied and given leeway to do things they shouldn’t do.
People tend to forget that begging is an age-old profession and an art, and beggars in SA have a veritable gold mine at their disposal – a wealthy segment of the population made up of people who enjoy their comforts and who want to steer clear of poverty, but at the same time, feel a sense of guilt because of their privilege.
Beggars exploit this to the max, providing an opportunity for “caring” folk to give away a few rand from the comfort of their cars to ease their conscience.
Unfortunately, beggars distract us from the true poverty in the country.
Many people want to give to the needy, but they don’t feel comfortable going into impoverished areas, so they end up offering their change to professional drifters who hang around shops, restaurants and other places where money changes hands.
These vagrants earn a lot compared to the 99% of really poor people in townships whom no-one sees because they won’t venture out and ask for money.
Beggars often defend their turf by brutal means to secure their business interests from other would-be competitors.
They tend to be crass and demanding, create unsafe conditions for the public and actually only make up a tiny percentage of the poor people in SA – but because they are conspicuous, they are seen as the face of “the poor”.
This makes them the worst sort of people to support.
If someone really wants to help those in need, then he or she could keep an eye open for people digging in bins, or for those who look really poor but are not asking for money.
It is not hard to identify such people. Approach them discreetly and give them a R50 or R100 note, or whatever sum one wants to donate.
True charity involves being proactive by putting aside a certain sum each month and using one’s mind and will to identify where help is really needed instead of being coerced to give when one doesn’t want to.
‘There seems to be a perception in SA that begging and selling goods constitutes a sufficient reason to be there’
Geoff Embling