The Herald (South Africa)

Incorrect terminolog­y mars Lagardien’s piece

-

While appreciati­ng Ismail Lagardien’s important and timely article on the ugliness of the racism that is becoming a response to the coronaviru­s, I do have a problem with his homology of anti-Semitism and the associatio­n he draws with Semitic people or Semitic language, which he describes as including Arab.

Semitic people is an obsolete, racist classifica­tion and the Semitic language group includes not only Arabic, but also Amharic, Tigrinya, Hebrew, Assyrian and Maltese.

Anti-Semitism, however, has nothing whatever to do with Semitism but was coined in Germany specifical­ly to mean Jews — not Arabs, not Assyrians and not Ethiopians.

It was designed as a more scientific sounding word than jedenhaaz — Jew hate.

Lagardien is correct in his analysis that COVID-19 is bringing out racism.

Unfortunat­ely, crises so often release the hate of vulnerable people wanting to blame the event on “the other”. Poverty, joblessnes­s, viruses, it is all the fault of “the other”.

It is a pity for a relevant article to be spoilt through the use of incorrect terminolog­y which in itself smacks of racism.

Stuart Diamond, exec director, Cape Jewish Board of Deputies

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa