The Independent on Saturday

Zuma has reached the end of legal road – analysts

- NTOMBI NKOSI ntombi.nkosi@inl.co.za

FORMER President Jacob Zuma has reached the end of the road after the Constituti­onal Court rejected his rescission applicatio­n yesterday.

Analysts said he could not play another card after the court’s decision.

Delivering judgment, Justice Sisi Khampepe said the majority ruling found Zuma did not meet the statutory requiremen­ts of a rescission.

“The majority emphatical­ly rejects any suggestion that litigants can be allowed to butcher, of their own will, judicial process which in all respects has been carried out with the utmost degree of regularity, only to later plead the absent victim. Elected absence like that of Mr Zuma constitute­s more than litigious skuldugger­y, which does not have the effect of turning a competentl­y granted order into one erroneousl­y granted,” said Justice Khampepe.

Political analyst Jamie Mighti said Zuma could not appeal the judgment.

“He cannot appeal unless he goes to an internatio­nal court, the African Court for Human and People’s rights, for example,” said Mighti.

Another political analyst, Dr Ralph Mathekga, said this was the end of the road for Zuma.

“Zuma has disrespect­ed the judiciary, deciding when to present himself. I think the court is sending a message,” Mathekga said.

The Council for the Advancemen­t of the South African Constituti­on (Casac) said this was now a closed matter. Casac research officer Dan Mafora said the judgment was a straightfo­rward matter.

“Rescission is a unique remedy that the courts don’t usually grant. We did not expect this case to be different, particular­ly because of the facts of the case of how it came about.”

Mafora said it was important because once there was no end to a litigation process, there was no legal certainty and people were not able to plan their lives, because they did not know what the law was.

Zuma is already on medical parole. Mafora said it was important to separate the two matters, the parole and the rescission applicatio­n. He said the two were completely different.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa