The Mercury

Not all criticism of Israel ‘anti-Semitic’

- ZAAKIR SAID | Durban

JEWISH groups employ a wellfunded, multi-pronged effort to harass and silence critics of Israel by labelling them anti-Semites. Despite what some pro-Israel organisati­ons would have us believe, not all criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic. Like all countries, Israel has a duty to uphold internatio­nal human rights laws.

Professor Marc Lamont Hill was fired from CNN as a commentato­r after some right-wing advocates for Israel objected to his UN speech defending the rights of Palestinia­ns.

Hill gave his speech on the Internatio­nal Day of Solidarity with the Palestinia­n people. He described Palestinia­ns’ worsening conditions and the Israeli government operating an apartheid regime and engaging in “settler colonialis­m” against the Palestinia­ns. The pro-Israeli rightwing outrage machine instantly branded Hill an anti-Semite, and accused him of “hate speech”.

CNN engages in selective protection of its journalist­s. Marc Lamont Hill is fired for his off the job opinion. So what is demonstrat­ed here? Without getting into the fine print of Hill’s contract – and it must be an unreadable size stating that if you are under contract with CNN while on personal time you cannot express an opinion on injustice against Palestinia­ns? Hill was likely targeted because CNN is not about free speech or equality for all people; just some political, religious and military bullies. CNN was absolutely cowardly in giving in to the pressure to fire him.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa