Weekend Argus (Saturday Edition)

How does religion define a nation?

-

COULD somebody please clarify the following issue in my mind?

If you are a South African Jew or a South African Muslim, are you a South African, or a Jew or a Muslim first and foremost?

If Jews are the followers/ practition­ers of Judaism, and Muslims that of Islam, how can any country base their nationalit­y on a certain religion when there are many other indigenous people in that country with their own religion, cultures and traditions. (SA is a great example).

I believe a country can only say it is called after a certain religion when 100% of the people practise that religion. Thus, can the Jews or any country call itself Jewish, Islamic or Buddhist if not 100% as stated above?

The promotion of such practises in the Middle East and some parts of the rest of the world can only be done via discrimina­tion, oppression, religious intoleranc­e and apartheid practices against the minority indigenous peoples of that part of the world.

Leaving all the Arab and “Islamic” countries aside for a moment, the question to Israel is: When you have Jews from all nationalit­ies coming to Palestine in droves, can you say that these Jews with their different nationalit­ies are more entitled to enjoy the Land of Palestine above the indigenous people of the land (which include Palestinia­n Jews)?

So now you deny and exclude the original inhabitant­s of Palestine their birthright­s, and by force and the help of others you declare Palestine to become Israel 70 years ago based on religion, even stolen by violence (with the help of God) 3 000 years ago.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa