Weekend Argus (Saturday Edition)
Parents discover babies were swopped 14 years ago
A KHAYELITSHA mom who discovered her baby was swopped at birth is desperate to meet her biological child.
The mother cannot be named to protect the identities of the two minor children.
In 2008, the mother gave birth to a boy. This was one of her happiest days she said. But today, it is a reminder her baby was swopped and she is demanding answers.
The mix-up was discovered only last year after the father of one of the boys questioned the paternity of the child, claiming there was no resemblance between them. He stopped financially supporting the child. DNA tests were done after the matter ended up in court and his suspicion was true.
Shocked by this, the woman also requested a test.
“The lab called and asked that they do another test as something did not seem right. I found out I, too, not the mother of the child.”
“The magistrate was rude to me at the time, even assuming that I stole the child. I do not know what happened, but the nurses must know something.”
The mother said she remembered the nurses taking the child to bathe him after birth and she did not notice that the baby had been swopped when they returned to her.
She said the child is facing health challenges and doctors cannot tell exactly what is wrong with him. She also believes that the other mother does not to take the child because of the challenges.
“He is earning a disability grant, he is a slow learner. I went to traditional healers who told me that unless the child performs his birth rite rituals, he will never be okay.”
Her biological child is raised by another family, also from Khayelitsha, but they are refusing to exchange the babies. She also blames the authorities for the slow pace in dealing with the matter.
“I have already told my child that he has another mother and he is looking forward to meeting her. I even lost my job because I am always attending meetings and court.”
In a joint statement, the Western Cape departments of Health and Social Development said in September 2021 they were alerted to this alleged incident and immediately started an investigation, which includes extensive counselling by a psychologist and a social worker.
“We have, and continue to engage the relevant parties. This process is thus ongoing. Generally, in matters of this nature, families require extensive, specialised counselling, mediation and support. Through the Social Development processes, both families must reach a mutual agreement about the way forward. If this doesn’t happen, a court process will follow to determine the way forward.”
Traditional healer and cultural activist Themba Sonkanyamba claimed the reason doctors cannot find anything wrong with the child is that he is not really sick but longing for his real ancestors.
“The biological family needs to do imbeleko for the child. The imbeleko ceremony introduces and welcomes a newborn child, but occasionally even an adult newcomer may be introduced to both the living and the ancestral spirits.”
Professor Larisse Prinsen, a senior lecturer at the University of Free State, said the parents may sue the hospital based on gross negligence.
Asked if it was a common occurrence that babies are swopped, he said: “It is difficult to say to what extent this is a problem. The reason for this is that many of these incidents never come to light, which hinders data collection. In the case at hand, for example, the true state of affairs was discovered by happenstance due to a maintenance-related paternity test. Had it not been for this test, the true parentage of the child would probably never have come to light.”
He added that it is difficult to predict what the courts may say. “Traditionally, courts endeavour to protect family units as much as possible. In this particular case, the testimony of experts such as psychologists and social workers will play a pivotal role. The will of the children themselves might also play a role as they are 14 years old. The most pivotal consideration, however, will be the best interest of the child as is mandated by the Constitution as well as the Children’s Act.”