Biden dons cap of union leader in Amazon clip
For a few minutes on Sunday night, President Joe Biden sounded a little like a union leader. “Unions put power in the hands of workers,” he said in a video statement of support for the union drive at an Amazon fulfillment centre in Bessemer, Alabama. “They level the playing field. They give you a stronger voice for your health, your safety, higher wages, protections from racial discrimination and sexual harassment. Unions lift up workers, both union and non-union, but especially black and brown workers.”
Mr Biden also spoke directly to employers who might try to subvert or sabotage an organising drive. “There should be no intimidation, no coercion, no threats, no anti-union propaganda. No supervisor should confront employees about their union preferences. Every worker should have a free and fair choice to join a union. The law guarantees that choice. And it’s your right, not that of an employer; it’s your right.”
Mr Biden is not the first president to speak in support of unions, but he may be the first to speak so publicly in their favour (certainly since Harry Truman). The words themselves are ordinary, but the context, an American president speaking in support of the most high-profile organising drive in the country, makes them extraordinary. And that, in turn, raises expectations for what Mr Biden can and should accomplish as president on behalf of the labour movement.
Typically, Democratic presidents aren’t so specific in their support for organised labour. Barack Obama, for example, stuck to platitudes at his 2015 White House summit on “worker voice.” “Labour unions were often the driving force for progress,” he said. “The middle class itself was built on a union label. And that middle class that was built was the engine of our prosperity.”
Before Mr Obama, Jennifer Klein, a professor of history at Yale, wrote by email, “Presidents Carter and Bill Clinton basically didn’t even believe there should be unions. They saw them as relics of a decidedly different era of American capitalism. Unions didn’t really function in a modern economy.”
Even Franklin Roosevelt was, as historian William E Leuchtenburg wrote in 1963, “somewhat perturbed at being cast in the role of midwife of industrial unionism.” When pressured by events to take a side in the “Little Steel” strike of May 1937 — in which steel workers under the CIO and the Steel Workers Organising Committee clashed with independent steel producers, their strikebreakers and law enforcement — Roosevelt blanched. “The majority of people are saying just one thing,” the president said. “A plague on both your houses.”
Compare this to Mr Biden, who stepped in during an organising drive and union election to support workers, rebuke hostile employers and remind the country the federal government has an obligation to allow or even encourage union organising. Relative to the rhetoric of most of his predecessors, Mr Biden’s brief address stands as one of the most pro-union statements ever issued from the White House. What is also striking is how the president’s statement reflects the changing nature of the labour movement. Mr Biden says unions help protect workers from sexual harassment and racial bias, and he ties the fight for union representation to the nation’s “reckoning on race” and the “deep disparities that still exist in our country.”
It is worth saying that most workers at the Amazon facility in Bessemer are black, and many of them are women. Across the country, black and Hispanic workers, especially women, are at the forefront of struggles for higher wages and greater dignity. Unions are diverse, and unionised workers are no longer just the hard hats and stevedores of the industrial age. “That is the old imagining of the union base,” said Kirsten Swinth, a professor of history at Fordham University. “But that’s not the reality of the American labour movement today. When Mr Biden speaks out the way he does, he is speaking to the working class that has come into being since the 1970s.”
Mr Biden’s statement will almost certainly reverberate through future organising campaigns, to be used against hostile employers. It also plants a flag for the Democratic Party, not just in favour of unions generally but worker power specifically. And to that end, it raises the urgency for pro-union executive action and pro-worker legislation. Last year, the House passed the Protecting the Right to Organise Act, which would grant workers new collective bargaining rights.
The Senate and its supermajority requirement for legislation could pose an obstacle. With that in mind, perhaps the best thing Mr Biden’s rhetoric can do is put more pressure on Democrats to bring majority rule to the chamber and let Congress finally govern on behalf of the country and its workers.