Time to reign in the lure of easy money
As top central bankers meet in the US to discuss global economy, they must make sure yet another bubble is avoided
ater this week, some of the cleverest people in the world will assemble at a very nice place — Jackson Hole, Wyoming — to talk at length about some extremely technical subjects. The content of their discussions would be baffling to anyone other than a trained economist. Yet, anything they say can be of huge importance to the livelihoods of billions of people — so much so that financial journalists will be hanging on every word as if they were Ancient Greeks waiting on the Oracle at Delphi. For these are the central bankers, the likes of Janet Yellen, head of the United States Federal Reserve (Fed), and Mario Draghi, the president of the European Central Bank.
What they say can instantly send stock and bond markets soaring or crashing, and what they do can change the price of everyone’s mortgage and, ultimately, determine the job prospects of vast numbers of people. Since the crash of 2008, which most of them spectacularly failed to foresee, the world has largely depended on these powerful individuals, along with their colleagues at the Bank of England, the Bank of Japan and so on, to keep the global economy growing despite a much weakened financial system. They have done that by driving interest rates lower for longer than ever before in history — even below zero in some cases, thus creating money and pumping it continually into financial markets. These policies, while necessary for a time, had gone on for too long and were starting to cause damage that might be greater than the good they were doing.
Continued for eight years after the crash, the central banks were giving short-term relief, but building up severe long-term problems. Many years of ultra-low interest rates discourage saving, and drive savers into riskier assets. They inflate property prices to ridiculous levels, and create stock market booms that benefit the wealthiest most, thus widening inequality and feeding political discontent. They reduce productivity by allowing firms that would normally go bust to stay in business, and encouraging successful firms to use cheap borrowed money to buy back shares, rather than plan new and productive investments. Most obviously, such a long period of easy money encourages the building up of large debts and people forget that interest rates can rise, leading to a new bubble.
Risk building up
The expectation is that any new head of the Fed, to be appointed next year, will be subject to tighter rules imposed by the president or the US Congress, so the erosion of independence has indeed begun. More worryingly, the runaway build-up of debt has continued. This is an international problem, notably in the US and China, but very clearly in the United Kingdom, too. British households now have billions of unsecured debts, surpassing the amount they had borrowed just before the last crisis. Such debts have recently been expanding at 10 per cent a year, or five times faster than the growth in wages. In Britain and the US, the car market has become the most dramatic example of what is happening. With nine out of 10 cars being sold with cheap finance, Americans have now run up more than a trillion dollars in car loans and the UK faces a comparable situation. The amounts involved are far smaller than the sub-prime mortgages that had triggered the crash in 2008, but they are representative of risk building up in millions of households and small firms who are now highly vulnerable to an economic downturn or a change in the direction of interest rates. So the brilliant brains gathering at Jackson Hole have a dilemma. Between them they have amassed some $15 trillion (Dh55.17 trillion) of bonds and don’t know how to sell them again. They have kept the world addicted to easy money and inflated markets for so long that they don’t know how to stop it. The message from the rest of us to this distinguished gathering should be: Get on with it and show you mean it. Pursue a clear strategy, rather than always finding an excuse for delay. New bubbles are forming and rate increases, albeit small and gradual, are a necessary way of preventing that from becoming unsustainable.
Furthermore, the next global recession will happen when you’re not expecting it and possibly for a reason you’ve never thought of. When it does, you will wish you had given yourselves some leeway. Finally, to you the central bankers, if it’s not your job to worry about the inequality, poor productivity, inadequate savings and misallocation of capital that results from permanent low interest rates, perhaps it ought to be. The side-effects of the drug of easy money have been borne for nearly a decade. If that happens for another decade, the drug might well become fatal. That would be a good subject for discussion round the table at Jackson Hole.
William Hague is the former UK foreign secretary and a former leader of the Conservative Party.