Kerry calls talk of better Iran nuclear deal a ‘fantasy’
washington — US Secretary of State John Kerry said on Thursday it is “fantasy plain and simple” to claim that President Barack Obama failed to insist on enough restraints on Iran’s nuclear programme before agreeing to lift economic sanctions long in place.
He challenged Republican lawmakers who want to torpedo the deal, saying “So what’s your plan? ... Totally go to war?”
Republicans were unpersuaded — and said so — at an occasionally contentious senate foreign relations committee hearing that marked the opening of a new phase in the administration’s drive to prevent Congress from undermining the accord.
“You guys have been bamboozled,” said Senator Jim Risch, a Republican, complaining that the agreement wouldn’t permit neutral testing at Iran’s Parchin military complex to guard against cheating.
The deal, reached earlier this month, will take effect unless Congress blocks it. Republicans in control of the House and Senate hope to do that by passing legislation in September to prevent Obama from lifting sanctions that lawmakers put in place over several years.
Obama has promised to veto any such bill. That would lead to a vote to override his veto, and the administration is searching for 34 votes in the Senate or 146 in the House to assure a veto would stick.
Democrats and allied independents control 46 seats in the Senate, and so far senators Dick Durbin, Dianne Feinstein and Martin Heinrich, all Democrats, have announced support for the plan. In the House, Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi has expressed optimism that a veto can be upheld.
The hearing unfolded as House Speaker John Boehner hinted at additional steps to stop the deal beyond the legislation, which is expected to be voted on after lawmakers return from an August vacation. “I think there’s a lot of tools at our disposal,” he told reporters, although he did not elaborate.
Given the political calculus, the senate hearing wasn’t so much an attempt by Kerry to persuade Republicans to support the plan as it was an opportunity to reassure Democrats.
Even so, no matter the objections — and Republicans levelled many in a hearing that stretched until midafternoon — Kerry, Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz and Treasury Secretary Jack Lew were ready with responses.
Kerry read supportive comments from former Israeli intelligence officials who hold views diametrically opposed to the ones held by radical prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, arguably the pact’s fiercest opponent.
He also said he expects support for the deal from Saudi Arabia. Half a world away, by coincidence or not, Foreign Minister Adel Al Jubeir said the agreement appears to have the provisions needed to curtail Iran’s ability to obtain a nuclear weapon. Saudi Arabia and Iran are fierce rivals, and Al Jubeir met separately with Kerry and Obama last week.
At its heart, the agreement calls for the United States and other world powers to end economic and military sanctions in exchange for concessions from Iran in its nuclear programme. Tehran says its programme is entirely peaceful, but the US and most other nations believe it is aimed at acquiring nuclear weapons. They imposed sanctions on Iran to bring it to the bargaining table.
Across more than four hours in the witness chair, Kerry sought repeatedly to blunt one of the Republicans’ core objections, that Obama settled for a less favourable deal than he could have gotten had he insisted on more.
“The alternative to the deal we’ve reached isn’t what we’re seeing ads for on TV,” he said, referring to commercials backed by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a lobbying group that strongly opposes the deal.
The United Nations Security Council has already voted to lift the international sanctions in place, effectively accepting the deal that the United States and other powers have struck with Iran.
As a result, administration officials say the US would be left trying to enforce more limited sanctions, without the support of other nations. —