Retail workers feel disruption
new york — With new options and conveniences, there’s never been a better time for shoppers. As for workers... well, not always.
The retail industry is being radically reshaped by technology, and nobody feels that disruption more starkly than 16 million American shelf stockers, salespeople, cashiers and others.
The shifts are driven, like much in retail, by the Amazon effect — the explosion of online shopping and the related changes in consumer behaviour and preferences.
As mundane tasks like checkout and inventory are automated, employees are trying to deliver the kind of customer service the Internet can’t match.
So a Best Buy employee who used to sell electronics in the store is dispatched to customers’ homes to help them choose just the right products. A Walmart worker dashes in and out of the grocery aisles, hand-picks products for online shoppers and brings them to people’s cars.
Yet even as responsibilities change — and in many cases, expand — the average growth in pay for retail workers isn’t keeping pace with the rest of the economy. Some companies say that in the long run the transformation could mean fewer retail workers, though they may be better paid. But while some workers feel more satisfied, others find their jobs are just a lot less fun.
Bloomingdale’s saleswoman Brenda Moses remembers the pre-Internet era, when the upscale store was regularly filled with customers ready to buy. These days, department stores are less crowded and the customers who do come in can make price comparisons on their phones at the same time as they pepper staff with questions.
“You tell them everything, and then they look at you and say, ‘You
Now, you have to fight to make your money Brenda Moses, Saleswoman at Bloomingdale’s
know what? I think I will get it online,’” she said.
Moses has seen her commission rate rise to six per cent from a half a per cent, but her hourly wage dropped from $19 as low as $10 before it came back up to $14. Depending more on commissions means her income fluctuates, and she’s competing with her colleagues for each sale.
“Now,” Moses said, “you have to fight to make your money.”
The same could be said for the retailing industry, overall. In 2017, 66,500 US retail jobs disappeared (not taking into account jobs added in areas like distribution and call centres). In the past decade, about one out of every seven jobs have vanished in the hardest-hit sectors like clothing and consumer electronics, says Frank Badillo, director of research at MacroSavvy. Though department stores have suffered the most, smaller businesses also have struggled to compete with online sellers. —