CAG finds flaws in acquisition of Apache and Chinook copters
new delhi — The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has found certain flaws in the acquisition of Apache Attack helicopters for which the US supplied life-expire missiles and the heavy lift helicopter-Chinook in September 2015.
On the Apache attack helicopter, the Audit found that Request for Proposals (RFP) was issued to seven vendors and only three responded. “All of them could not meet the full set of Air Staff Qualitative Requirements (ASQRs). The tender process was cancelled. The ASQR parameters which could not be met were charged/deleted and fresh tendering was done. If these ASQR parameters were not needed, they should not have been included in the first place,” it said.
After re-tendering, the vendors could not still meet the RFP requirements and the Defence Ministry was contemplating retendering for a second time. However, after much deliberation, it was approved with deviations. This took 36 weeks against the prescribed four weeks.
The report said the ASQRs were changed based on the advice of Boeing. Contract was finally awarded to Boeing for Apache helicopters.
The RFP required the vendor to offer transfer of technology for maintenance of helicopters. A separate contract was to be signed for maintenance.
Before signing the contract, Boeing convinced the Defence Ministry that transfer of technology and maintenance in India would not be cost effective in view of the small quantity of helicopters. —