Dead hand of ‘supervisory bodies’ at work in Iran, president claims

Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani said yesterday that officials were failing to respond effectively to mounting popular protests, in part because they are being threatened by unnamed behind-the-scenes forces.

In recent weeks, social media has been filled with videos and reports of protests, but since they are barely covered by domestic media and access is restricted for foreign journalists, they have been hard to verify.

They include protests by farmers over water shortages in Isfahan; by ethnic Arabs over the treatment of minorities in the southern province of Khuzestan; and over administrative reforms in the southwestern city of Kazeroon.

The videos appear to show these localised protests taking on broader slogans against the establishment, such as: “Our enemy is right here and falsely they say America is our enemy”.

But in a wide-ranging speech carried on state television, Mr Rouhani said officials were failing to respond and appeared to have taken “a vow of silence”.

“As people haven’t got enough information … as people don’t see plans for the future, as people see the current problems, they may get upset and angry, come to the streets and cry out,” he told senior officials in Tehran.

“[But] we speak little to the people. Our government managers have taken a vow of silence. I don’t know who told them to. I don’t know what they are scared of.”

Mr Rouhani said a major problem was that officials were being intimidated by unnamed “supervisory bodies”.

He did not name them, but Mr Rouhani has clashed with the powerful Revolutionary Guard and the conservative-dominated judiciary over their outsized role in politics and the economy.

“When in the morning [an official] is going to work, somebody sends him a text message, another calls him, another threatens him … the country cannot be run like this,” he said.

In the past month, Tehran’s reformist mayor, Mohammad-Ali Najafi and the deputy head of the environment agency, Kaveh Madani, both quit their posts after pressure from hardliners, although Mr Najafi claimed he left for health reasons.

“Don’t pay attention to some letters, some threats. If you are scared to respond, send them to me,” Mr Rouhani said.

The president also appeared to criticise the morality police in his speech after a video emerged of a woman being beaten in the street for breaching the strict dress code.

“Some say the way to promote virtue and prohibit vice is ... by going to the street and grabbing people by the neck,” Mr Rouhani said.

“Promoting virtue will not work through violence.”

On Thursday, footage of a female member of the morality police beating a woman whose headscarf was deemed to not sufficiently cover her hair went viral.

The video prompted outrage on social media and the interior ministry promised an investigation, but also implied the woman may have provoked the violence by swearing at the police.

Mr Rouhani did not refer directly to the case, but appeared to use it to criticise recent efforts to clamp down on social media networks.

“Mobiles are the way to promote virtue and prohibit vice. I don’t know why some people don’t like mobile phones or social networks,” he said.

“They don’t like people having information. They think if people are in total ignorance, they can sleep better at night.

“Being informed is people’s right ... criticism is people’s right,” he said. “Let people live their lives.”

There is mounting pressure to block foreign social media networks such as Telegram, which are the only way to spread information critical of Iran’s Islamic system.

But Mr Rouhani said uncensored networks were vital to the economy, and warned that the Islamic revolution of 1979 would ultimately be judged by the regime’s behaviour towards its people.

“If our behaviour has gotten worse [since 1979], then this revolution is on the wrong path. The fundamental purpose of the revolution is to respect people and solve their problems,” he said.

“Whatever we want to do, if we convince people rather than threaten them ... we will succeed.”

Mr Rouhani’s barbs were directed at military and religious interests within Iran whose power goes far beyond their bounds