Is Turkey trying to mend its relations with Europe?
The UAE and Cyprus signed a defence co-operation deal last week, a month after the UAE became a permanent observer member of the EastMed Gas Forum and two months after the Emirates and Athens agreed to broader defence co-operation. The international body, widely seen as a bulwark to Turkish influence in the Mediterranean, appears to be gaining strength.
Yet there have also been signs of an opening to Ankara. “We want to tell Turkey that we want normal relations with it that respect mutual sovereignty,” UAE Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Dr Anwar Gargash told Sky News Arabia just before the UAE-Cyprus deal. “We don’t have any problems with Turkey.”
A few days earlier, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain and Egypt announced the end of a three-and-a-half-year freeze on diplomatic, trade and travel ties with Qatar – a move that could clear the way for improved relations between Gulf states and Turkey, an ally of Doha.
A hopeful Turkey, meanwhile, has put on its flirtiest smile. After pushing each other to the brink of war last summer, Ankara and Athens are set to launch exploratory talks next week, to address conflicting maritime claims and drilling rights in the Eastern Mediterranean.
Retired naval officer Cihat Yayci, the architect of Turkey’s regional Blue Homeland doctrine, has warned that talks with Greece could destroy Turkey’s position in Libya and the Eastern Mediterranean. But Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has hailed the negotiations as “a harbinger of a new era”, and last week said that Turkey is ready to put its frayed relations with the EU back on track.
A new era may also be on the wing for Cyprus, which since a 1974 invasion by Turkish forces has been divided between the Greek-backed Republic of Cyprus, an EU member, and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, recognised only by Turkey. Several rounds of reunification talks have failed, most recently in 2017.
UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres plans to meet next month with leaders of Greek and Turkish Cyprus, and representatives from Greece, Turkey and the UK to determine whether talks can resume. Since Ersin Tatar became TRNC president in October, Turkey and Turkish Cypriots have more strongly backed a two-state solution, as opposed to reunification.
Ankara has also been hinting at rapprochement with Egypt. Relations between the two regional powers have been frosty since 2013 saw the fall of Mohammed Morsi’s Muslim Brotherhood government in Cairo and Turkey’s welcoming of the extremist organisation’s exiled leaders. Writing for the European Council on Foreign Relations, ECFR pan-European junior fellow Matteo Colombo urged European states to encourage Ankara-Cairo talks to help reduce tensions in Libya and the Eastern Mediterranean. “They should look to build on the Turkish government’s reported outreach to its rival behind closed doors in recent weeks,” writes Mr Colombo.
There have been reports in recent weeks that Muslim Brotherhood leaders have begun leaving Turkey. They have been joined in doing so by members of Hamas, viewed as a terrorist group by Israel and the US but regularly hosted by Ankara. Over the past month, Turkey has sent several signals – including a comment from Mr Erdogan – that it seeks to strengthen relations with Israel. Israeli officials plan to meet Turkish counterparts in private, but have expressed concerns that Ankara’s newly friendly stance is mainly about winning points with incoming US president Joe Biden.
Israel “has reacted coolly so far to the mostly insubstantial hints of a change in Turkish attitudes, and will take great care not to harm its deepened strategic co-operation with Greece and Cyprus,” writes Joshua Krasna, senior fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute.
One of the main reasons Mr Erdogan has shifted to a more conciliatory tone recently is, of course, money. He hopes to attract foreign capital to boost Turkey’s troubled economy, which in the days ahead must overcome US sanctions and, potentially, EU sanctions.
The ides of March may decide Turkey’s fate, when the EU will meet to consider harsher sanctions against Turkey for its aggressions in the Eastern Mediterranean and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will face yet another election. Looking to calm the waters, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu plans to meet EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell in Brussels this week, before Mr Erdogan meets European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen later this month.
If the EU holds off on stronger sanctions and the increasingly hardline Mr Netanyahu fails to hold on to power, Turkey could gain ground in the eyes of European and Eastern Mediterranean rivals, as well as the US. Mr Erdogan could use all the help he can get with Mr Biden, who is preparing to take office on January 20 and has reportedly ignored the longtime Turkish leader’s request to talk.
Mr Erdogan’s first chance to boost his international standing in the Biden era comes a week from today, when Turkey and Greece sit down for their first diplomatic talks in five years. A breakthrough is highly unlikely, but a measure of open-mindedness and a willingness to engage from the Turkish side could begin to change the narrative.
Mr Erdogan said the talks are ‘a harbinger of a new era,’ and that Turkey is ready to repair its frayed relations with the EU