Coroner: Fatal fall from coach was an accident
HOSPITAL FROM INJURY ON SAGA TRIP
A GRANDMOTHER from Farnham suffered a “heartbreaking” fatal fall from a coach while on holiday in Norway, dying abroad at Stavanger University Hospital after her life support was withdrawn.
Catherine Betty Fitzgerald, known as Betty, was 79 at the time of her death on October 6 2022. The grandmother fell after missing a step at the top of the coach as she exited the vehicle. The incident occurred during a day excursion to see the Northern Lights at the Norwegian Fjords with Saga Cruises, a trip on which she travelled solo.
Mrs Fitzgerald hit the back of her head on the concrete quayside and suffered a bleed to her brain called a subdural haematoma as a result of the head injury. Her death was ruled accidental by coroner Christopher Wilkinson, who found that due to a vision impairment in her left eye and the safety strip at the top of the steps being slightly obscured by the carpet of the coach, Mrs Fitzgerald misjudged where the step began and ended, thus falling.
Daniel Mann, the head of safety, policy and assurance at Saga cruises, told an inquest at Winchester Coroner’s Court on Monday last week: “Slips, trips and falls are not uncommon amongst our target age group.”
A safety check was conducted that day but the checklist could not be located, he added.
Mrs Fitzgerald’s daughter, Pauline Parrott, 57, from Farnham, was critical of the company and claims communication was poor when she found out about her mum’s fall while at home. She said she received a phone call from the UK Saga customer service team, which “turned [her] life upside down”.
The customer service team said Ms Parrott could get a flight out to Norway. She claims the initial caller was not aware of the severity of her mum’s fall. It was not until she got the number of the hospital in Norway that doctors told her that Betty only had two hours to live.
Ms Parrott said: “I just had to sit and wait for a call to confirm that she hadn’t made it. I wouldn’t have time to fly out there. I felt helpless, it was all so upsetting.”
At the time, Saga only dispatched a medical representative for those on a cruise for 11 days or more. Therefore, Mrs Fitzgerald was not eligible to have a member of staff by her side when she travelled to hospital and died alone after the hospital decided to withdraw life support just three hours after the accident.
Ms Parrott told the coroner’s court: “I think passengers would be shocked by some of the things you think are acceptable. There was a serious lack in communication regarding the severity of her injuries and support for the family. No one would want their parent alone in distress.
“This is all very difficult to understand given the age of their clients and the admission from Saga’s head of safety that ‘slips and trips are commonplace.’ Mum dying alone is truly heartbreaking, we would have loved to have been by her side when the life support was switched off.”
One witness, Derek Wilson, said in a statement that the steps were quite steep and that was no Saga staff on the ground to help passengers off the coach. John Michael Morley, another witness, said in his statement that the sound of Mrs Fitzgerald hitting the floor was terrible, and also corroborated that there should have been staff on the ground to help.
Coroner Mr Wilkinson said he did not believe Mrs Fitzgerald tripped on the scuffed carpet, but he was concerned that the safety strip may have been obscured. Along with her limited vision, she may have anticipated the step to be closer than it was.
He concluded: “My view is that the death was accidental and nothing could have been done. It is regrettable that the rep was not able to get off the coach first as they should have done and was not able to be present.
“Given the fact that she fell from the top step I do not believe there is likely much someone could have done being at the bottom of the stairs, and it may have caused them injuries.”
It was recommended by the coroner that a designated seat for representatives is set aside by the exits, so they can get off first.
Oral warnings about taking care of the steps should be given every time the bus stops, similar to when disembarking the Tube in London, and written signs should be put up.
The coroner added: “It is a desperate and very sad event leading to the loss of life of Catherine ‘Betty’ Fitzgerald and the distress felt by the family trying to deal with her death. I hope you have very fond memories of her.”
A spokesman for Saga, said: “Our thoughts and condolences remain with the family of Mrs Fitzgerald following this tragic accident.
“We have been fully supportive of the inquest and provided all assistance to the coroner.”