British Railway Modelling (BRM)
REVIEW: LYNTON & BARNSTAPLE RAILWAY LYN
Phil Parker takes a closer look at the new Lyn from Heljan, a model that has potential for use well beyond the North Devon line the prototype ran on.
Along project to recreate the Lynton & Barnstaple Railway's long-lost Baldwin 2-4-2T Lyn finally came to fruition in 2017, when the new locomotive entered service on the Devon line. The efforts of the 762 Club – a group that spearheaded the new-build – was bound to spark the interest of model makers. Having already produced an L&B Manning Wardle, it was perhaps no surprise that Heljan chose the Baldwin as their next model.
The real-life locomotive was built for the Lynton & Barnstaple Railway in 1898 – the line had quickly concluded it needed more motive power alongside its three 2-6-2Ts ordered from Manning Wardle, but at the time industrial action at many UK builders had created a backlog of orders. US manufacturer, Baldwin could deliver a loco more quickly.
Lyn was shipped across the Atlantic in parts and erected at the L&B's Pilton Works by railway staff, first steaming in July 1898. Thereafter, it went straight into service on the line, making few headlines until after the takeover by the Southern Railway in 1923.
A major overhaul was carried out at the Southern's Eastleigh works near Southampton in 1928, the locomotive returning in Southern livery and with the designation E762. Lyn then continued working until the line's closure in 1935. At the subsequent auction, the only interest in the Baldwin came from scrap merchants, who rapidly cut it up in Pilton Works.
With the L&B revival progressing well, the 762 Club was formed in 2009 to build a new Lyn, externally similar to the original,
but with the benefit of modern engineering technology. The locomotive was completed in 2017 and has run on the Devon line ever since, looking particularly splendid at the head of a rake of four brilliantly-restored (with mostly new parts) L&B carriages.
Heljan is offering the model in six different versions, reflecting detail and livery changes in the locomotive's career:
• Plain works black (likely to be of particular interest to those wanting their model for fictitious layouts not following an L&B theme)
• Pre-1906 L&B green, when the locomotive name was stencilled on the cab-side
• Post-1906 L&B, with a different shade of green, changed lining and proper cab-side nameplates
• As between 1923 and 1928, when the locomotive was in Southern Railway ownership, still wearing its original livery but with the nameplates relocated to the cab sides
• As the locomotive returned from its 1928 overhaul in Southern apple-green livery
• In its final years between 1932 and '35, with some detail changes
The review sample is in the 1907-1923 condition, the last years of independent ownership.
Narrow Gauge World Editor, Andrew Charman, spent some time consulting every L&B history book in the NGW library, comparing the period imagery to the model, and concluded that this is a pretty faithful reproduction.
The only question was whether the tank lining should be continued on the tank fronts, which are plain green. All the photos we could find are inconclusive on this one, the black and white imagery of the time merging the different tones together and it's not obvious whether the prototype's tank fronts were plain in this period or with lining. We'll give Heljan the benefit of the doubt, as the livery application is excellent.
The careful attention to detail is clear to see when comparing different versions of the model. Our example does not have the plug on the side of the smokebox used for removing ash, because this plate was removed in 1907.
The relocation of the whistle from cab front to cab roof is faithfully reproduced, although both this and the dome-mounted safety valve are very fragile. However, the different safety valve designs and variety of smokebox doors are modelled correctly.
The model comes with a six-pin socket for DCC control, fitted just behind the smokebox. Access requires the ponies to be released, then three screws removed,
datafile BASICS
pipes and stays prised from the smokebox and then the plastic body eased away from the diecast chassis. Full instructions are provided, but it's a bit fiddly. If you plan to fit a crew, it makes sense to do this at the same time.
On the track, the model runs very smoothly, aided by pick-ups on all four driving wheels and the rear pony truck. From this good starting point, even a very short period of operation saw a noticeable improvement as the mechanism ran-in. The headlamp illuminates when the model is running forward.
Two issues arose – firstly, in negotiating Peco points of the tightest radius, the locomotive hesitated and needed a bit more power on the controller. In fairness, Heljan quotes that a minimum radius of 305mm is employed for Lyn, but adds that larger radii will suit it better, as would be expected of a large locomotive such as this. As the model ran-in, this performance improved, but it's worth bearing in mind if your line has very tight curves.
The second is the cowcatchers, provided separately in the packing. These etched items are easy to install, but rubbed on the coupling block, reducing the pony's swing. If this is a problem, they will need to be left off or modified. Without them, the locomotive coupled perfectly to the Bachmann and Peco rolling stock we tested.
Overall, this is a superb model with plenty of potential for use well beyond the North Devon line the prototype ran on.
Manufacturer: Heljan
Catalogue Refs:
9980: Works black unnumbered
9981: L&BR dark green (pre-1906)
9982: L&BR dark green (post 1906)
9983: Southern ex-L&B green
9984: Southern Maunsell green (pre-1932)
9985: Southern Maunsell green (post-1932)
RRP: £239.95
Era: 1906 – preservation
Company/operator: Lynton & Barnstaple Railway/Southern Railway
Weight: 89g
Chassis and Body: Die-cast chassis and running plate and plastic body.
Minimum curve radius: 305mm
Accessories: Cowcatchers