The Blue Boy: a window on history
YESTERDAY—EXACTLY a century after it was last seen on public display in Britain on January 25, 1922—The Blue Boy by Thomas Gainsborough returned on loan from the Huntington Art Museum, in San Marino, California, to the walls of the National Gallery, London. It’s the first time it has travelled since 1922 and will remain on display here as part of a free exhibition until May 15. Athena would warmly encourage her readers to take advantage of the opportunity and that’s not only because this is a magnificent painting.
A Portrait of a Young Gentleman, as it was entitled when first exhibited to acclaim in the Royal Academy exhibition of 1770, is an artistic essay in the manner of Anthony Van Dyck (1599–1641), a defining figure in the tradition of British portraiture. It shows a full-length portrait of a boy— his identity is not known—staring straight out of the canvas at the viewer. His 17thcentury costume of rippling blue silk won the painting its familiar modern name by 1798. The boy stands against a dark background, with one hand placed confidently on his hip and the other holding a plumed hat. A shaft of light from high above illuminates his face, emphasising his ruddy cheeks and ruby lips.
This striking portrait grew steadily in celebrity over the 19th century and was loaned widely by the Duke of Westminster including, in 1908, to an exhibition of the best English art displayed in the Berlin Royal Academy to promote Anglo-german understanding. The status and celebrity it enjoyed were further illustrated in 1921
Works of art with historic celebrity challenge us to understand what previous generations saw
when the American railway magnate, Henry E. Huntington (1850–1927) purchased The Blue Boy for $728,000. It was then the largest sum ever paid for a painting.
In a three-week valedictory exhibition at the National Gallery, 90,000 people travelled to see it. As the canvas was packed up, the director, hopeful that it would one day return, wrote ‘Au revoir’ in pencil on the back. And now it has.
The irony of all this is that, for all its former celebrity as an icon of Englishness, The Blue Boy returns home in 2022 with vastly reduced popular recognition. Nor, Athena would venture, will it be easy for a modern viewer to see reflected in it much that they could identify with as English. We can enjoy this superb painting, in other words, but the idea of it as a mirror to our history and identity simply doesn’t ring true any more.
There are other works of art whose historic celebrity must mystify the modern viewer in much the same way; the Preraphaelite Holman Hunt’s The Light of the World (1853) springs to mind. They challenge us to understand what previous generations saw in them. In the process, they should make us reflect on how puzzling our own cultural fixations might seem in the future.