Daily Mail




Ex­clu­sive: Bri­tain’s best con­sul­tants – as cho­sen by their fel­low doc­tors

WHAT are the hall­marks of a good doc­tor? Skill and tech­ni­cal ex­per­tise, of course. But also vi­tal is some­one who un­der­stands you and some­one you trust.

In fact, re­search has proved that a good re­la­tion­ship with a doc­tor can ac­tu­ally im­prove your chances of a suc­cess­ful out­come. But how do you find a spe­cial­ist who fits the bill?

That’s where this unique se­ries of guides, which started in Satur­day’s Mail and con­tin­ues ev­ery day this week, can help you out.

We have iden­ti­fied the coun­try’s top con­sul­tants — as judged by their peers. We’ve can­vassed the views of more than 260 of them, across seven spe­cial­i­ties, and asked them this very sim­ple, but key, ques­tion: ‘If your own near­est and dear­est were to need treat­ment in your field, to whom would you re­fer them — and why?’

The con­sul­tants who earned the most votes from their peers are the ones who made it into our guides.

Pa­tients should bear in mind, though, that this is not a sci­en­tific study and there are many su­perb, highly skilled pro­fes­sion­als na­tion­wide who didn’t make it on to our list, but who are mak­ing a real dif­fer­ence to pa­tients ev­ery day.

To help you make in­formed choices about your own care, or that of your loved ones, we’ve also talked to ex­perts about the very lat­est think­ing on var­i­ous treat­ment op­tions.

To­day, we look at the best doc­tors for heart rhythm prob­lems.


MORE than two mil­lion peo­ple in the UK have a faulty heart­beat, or ar­rhyth­mia. Un­for­tu­nately, up to half-a-mil­lion go un­di­ag­nosed and, as their con­di­tion hasn’t been spot­ted and, there­fore, treated, their risk of stroke is sig­nif­i­cantly raised. The good news for those who

have been di­ag­nosed is that there’s been a rev­o­lu­tion in the treat­ment of heart rhythm disor­ders in re­cent years.

These disor­ders oc­cur when the heart’s elec­tri­cal cir­cuits, re­spon­si­ble for keep­ing it pump­ing, be­come scram­bled, send­ing faulty mes­sages that over­ride the heart’s nat­u­ral pace­maker, a clus­ter of cells known as the si­nus node. This prob­lem can be some­thing you were born with or a con­se­quence of coro­nary heart dis­ease or age­ing.

Ar­rhyth­mias can range from a slow heart­beat, where the or­gan can’t pump enough blood around the body, to the most dan­ger­ous form, ven­tric­u­lar fib­ril­la­tion — the lat­ter can be fa­tal with­out rapid emer­gency treat­ment.

Symp­toms range from the mild to the alarm­ing. Your heart may seem to flut­ter or skip beats. Or it can race like mad, even though you’re just qui­etly watch­ing TV. Or you might find yourself sud­denly ex­hausted, short of breath and prone to faint­ing.

The most com­mon ar­rhyth­mia is atrial fib­ril­la­tion, which causes a fast, chaotic heart­beat. This tends to oc­cur mostly in peo­ple over the age of 60 and af­fects around a mil­lion Bri­tons.

Here, ran­dom elec­tri­cal charges cause the up­per cham­bers of the heart (called the atria) to quiver, af­fect­ing the heart’s abil­ity to pump blood ef­fi­ciently.

The most se­ri­ous con­se­quence of un­treated atrial fib­ril­la­tion is stroke, be­cause the heart’s fee­ble pump­ing ac­tion al­lows blood to pool, caus­ing clots, which can break off and travel to the brain. This is why one of the first steps in treat­ing the con­di­tion is blood-thin­ning med­i­ca­tion.

What­ever the type of ar­rhyth­mia, med­i­ca­tion can be used to try to con­trol or pre­vent it.

Other op­tions in­clude giv­ing a shock to the heart in or­der to re­store a nor­mal rhythm, or im­plant­ing a pace­maker or an ICD (im­plantable car­dioverter de­fib­ril­la­tor), which gives an elec­tric shock if an ab­nor­mal heart rhythm is de­tected.

A min­i­mally in­va­sive al­ter­na­tive is catheter ab­la­tion. This non­sur­gi­cal pro­ce­dure is be­com­ing the gold stan­dard way to re­solve prob­lems with heart rhythm, par­tic­u­larly atrial fib­ril­la­tion, says Philippa Hob­son, a se­nior car­diac nurse at the Bri­tish Heart Foun­da­tion.

It is per­formed by an ex­pert car­di­ol­o­gist, known as an elec­tro­phys­i­ol­o­gist, and takes be­tween two and four hours. A thin wire with an elec­trode at its tip is threaded through the veins — usu­ally start­ing in the thigh — to the heart to cre­ate scar tis­sue, ei­ther with heat or freez­ing, to de­stroy rogue tis­sue re­spon­si­ble for send­ing faulty sig­nals, or ef­fec­tively block ab­nor­mal elec­tri­cal cir­cuits in the heart.

How­ever, as one lead­ing car­di­ol­o­gist told us, it would be a dread­ful shame ‘if the tech­no­log­i­cal de­mands eclipsed the hu­man side’.

Dr Ed­ward Row­land, who is based at St Bartholome­w’s Hos­pi­tal in Lon­don, says that em­pa­thy and a car­ing at­ti­tude are im­por­tant, too — par­tic­u­larly when pa­tients are wor­ried.

Suc­cess­fully treat­ing pa­tients, he sug­gests, is not just about the ab­la­tion op­er­a­tion, but how the pa­tient is treated in the run-up to it and their aftercare.

‘When your heart starts go­ing crazy and you think you are go­ing to die, it is not sur­pris­ing that pa­tients can be­come very anx­ious,’ says Dr Row­land.

‘Tech­ni­cal ex­per­tise is very im­por­tant — but this has to be ac­com­pa­nied by other hu­man fac­tors to pro­duce the best re­sults pos­si­ble.

‘There are some car­di­ol­o­gists who are excellent tech­ni­cally, but you would not nec­es­sar­ily send your clos­est fam­ily to them.’

So, how do you find an elec­tro­phys­i­ol­o­gist equipped with not just the tech­no­log­i­cal nous, but also the bed­side man­ner that can help peo­ple con­quer a dis­tress­ing, and some­times dis­abling, dis­ease?

We asked 40 con­sul­tants across

the coun­try who they be­lieve are the top per­form­ers. Here, we re­veal their choices — along with some of their rea­sons for se­lect­ing them.



ABOUT HIM: ‘ He was one of the very first to push atrial fib­ril­la­tion ab­la­tion in the UK and this has had a mas­sive and pos­i­tive im­pact on the lives of so many peo­ple — he is very skilled at it,’ says one of his peers.

‘He’s a great pa­tient cham­pion and works closely with the Ar­rhyth­mia Al­liance, a net­work of spe­cial­ists, pa­tient groups and char­i­ties, try­ing to raise aware­ness of these con­di­tions and im­prove di­ag­no­sis and treat­ment.

‘He’s also made an im­mense aca­demic con­tri­bu­tion to the sub­ject of ar­rhyth­mias as a key re­searcher,’ says an­other.

‘This mat­ters to pa­tients be­cause it is a sign of some­one keen to de­velop and re­fine treat­ments.’

PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Lon­don Bridge Hos­pi­tal.

DERICK TODD Liver­pool Heart and Chest Hos­pi­tal


ABOUT HIM: ‘A ter­rific op­er­a­tor and a lovely guy with im­pres­sive depth of skills,’ ac­cord­ing to one of his peers. ‘ He is com­pas­sion­ate, a good lis­tener, tech­ni­cally very ca­pa­ble and highly in­tel­li­gent.

‘He is also a huge be­liever in the power of au­dit­ing his unit’s re­sults — this close scru­tiny is the way to im­prove, as it is the only way to mea­sure what you’re do­ing right and where things could im­prove.’

‘Dr Todd pi­o­neered the treat­ment of chil­dren with heart rhythm disor­ders where — be­cause you’re work­ing on a far tinier scale — the risks are higher and the need to be excellent is paramount,’ says an­other of his peers.

‘Out­side of St Bartholome­w’s Hos­pi­tal in Lon­don, his Liver­pool base is now the largest heart cen­tre in the coun­try. Pa­tients should be as­sured they are get­ting the best.

‘Derick is the per­son I’d go to for ab­la­tion for atrial fib­ril­la­tion.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Spire Cheshire Hos­pi­tal.

ED­WARD ROW­LAND St Bartholome­w’s Hos­pi­tal in Lon­don


ABOUT HIM: ‘One of the most re­spected elec­trop h y s i o l o g i s t s [ the branch of car­di­ol­ogy that treats heart rhythm prob­lems] in the coun­try,’ ac­cord­ing to one who nom­i­nated him. ‘He is highly ex­pe­ri­enced and tech­ni­cally good, which means he can ma­nip­u­late very small wires in the heart.’

‘He is “old school” in a good way and is charm­ing, re­as­sur­ing, a great com­mu­ni­ca­tor and ex­tremely skilled, but he is not ob­sessed with the tech­nol­ogy,’ re­veals an­other.

‘He takes a holis­tic view of what will be best by weigh­ing very care­fully the risks and ben­e­fits of treat­ing his pa­tients and will say no to treat­ment if he feels this is in the pa­tient’s best in­ter­est.

‘He would be my first choice for my­self.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: The Har­ley Street Clinic and Bupa Cromwell Hos­pi­tal, both in Lon­don.


‘On the lead­ing edge, he has built an in­ter­na­tional rep­u­ta­tion based on his pro­lific re­search work,’ is the ver­dict of one of his peers. ‘ He is also known to pro­vide a mea­sured opin­ion on what is best for pa­tients.’

An­other car­di­ol­o­gist says: ‘He’s an ex­tremely as­tute doc­tor, par­tic­u­larly in di­ag­nos­tics. He will look at pa­tients very ob­jec­tively and pick up very sub­tle clinical signs that oth­ers could over­look.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Lon­don Heart Rhythm Group and The Har­ley Street Clinic in Lon­don.

STEPHEN MUR­RAY Free­man Hos­pi­tal in New­cas­tle


ABOUT HIM: ‘ He has great em­pa­thy and knows what he is talk­ing about,’ says one of his peers. ‘He’s also tech­ni­cally very good.

‘ He di­rects a highly pro­duc­tive and in­no­va­tive unit — he has adopted new tech­niques for iden­ti­fy­ing the origin of heart rhythm prob­lems, par­tic­u­larly in atrial fib­ril­la­tion.’

‘He’s also worked hard on achiev­ing the most ef­fi­cient use of re­sources. That mat­ters be­cause mis­takes cost money and, if you’re pru­dent with your fund­ing, there is more money for in­no­va­tion,’ says an­other of his peers.

‘He works hard to boost pro­fes­sional stan­dards

and he is also very per­son­able and de­ter­mined — he won’t give up on a pa­tient.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Free­man hos­pi­tal in New­cas­tle.


(Pic­tured be­low) John Rad­cliffe Hos­pi­tal in Oxford WHAT THEY SAY ABOUT HIM: ac­cord­ing to one car­di­ol­o­gist, He e is a ris­ing star in elec­tro­phys­i­ol­ogy [the branch of car­di­ol­ogy that treats heart rhythm disor­ders]. ‘He has great em­pa­thy, and what we call in medicine “good hands”, as well as a won­der­fully friendly ap­proach to pa­tients and a steely de­ter­mi­na­tion never to give up on them when lesser car­di­ol­o­gists might.’ An­other re­veals: ‘ He has a grow­ing in­ter­na­tional pro­file as a re­sult of his re­search. ‘ How­ever, most im­por­tantly, with his en­thu­si­asm and quiet con­fi­dence, he car­ries his pa­tients with him.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Nuffield Health The Manor Hos­pi­tal in Oxford.


John Rad­cliffe Hos­pi­tal in Oxford WHAT THEY SAY

ABOUT HIM: ‘ He has excellent per­sonal qual­i­ties and is easy­go­ing, hum­ble and un­der­stand­ing,’ says one of his peers.

‘Some pa­tients who suf­fer from ar­rhyth­mias are very fas­tid­i­ous and high­main­te­nance per­son­al­i­ties who, as a re­sult, may come in to see him armed with a sched­ule of the time of on­set and ending of an episode of their atrial fib­ril­la­tion.

‘While some might prickle at this ap­proach, he doesn’t, and pa­tients re­ally like him. He also does an enor­mous num­ber of pro­ce­dures and has great ex­pe­ri­ence.’

Ac­cord­ing to an­other of his peers: ‘In ad­di­tion, he has got what we in medicine call “great hands”. In other words, ma­nip­u­lat­ing the wires into the heart seems ef­fort­less to him. This takes huge skill to do well.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Nuffield Health The Manor Hos­pi­tal in Oxford.


St Mary’s Hos­pi­tal in Lon­don


ABOUT HIM: The con­sul­tant who treated for­mer Prime Min­is­ter To n y Blair’s ar­rhyth­mia back in 2004 is ‘seen as a fa­ther of elec­tro­phys­i­ol­ogy [ the branch of car­di­ol­ogy that treats heart rhythm prob­lems]’, is the ver­dict of one of his peers.

He has an excellent tech­ni­cal abil­ity and ‘ abun­dant hu­man qual­i­ties that would mat­ter if I needed a car­di­ol­o­gist for my clos­est rel­a­tive,’ re­veals an­other.

The Har­ley Street Clinic in Lon­don. PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE:


John Rad­cliffe Hos­pi­tal in Oxford WHAT THEY SAY

ABOUT HIM: ‘Re­ally fan­tas­tic, in­cred­i­bly nice, con­sid­er­ate and a font of knowl­edge,’ says one car­di­ol­o­gist.

‘ He also has one of the best elec­tro­phys­i­ol­ogy brains in the coun­try [elec­tro­phys­i­ol­ogy is the branch of car­di­ol­ogy that treats heart rhythm prob­lems]. He is care­ful to try to take on board the pa­tient’s view on treat­ment.’

‘Wis­dom cou­pled with com­mon sense,’ adds an­other of his peers.

Nuffield Health The Manor Hos­pi­tal in Oxford. PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE:


The Heart Hos­pi­tal and Great Or­mond Street Hos­pi­tal, Lon­don WHAT THEY SAY

ABOUT HIM: ‘ He takes on ex­tremely com­plex cases, par­tic­u­larly with chil­dren and adults born with heart prob­lems,’ ac­cord­ing to one of his peers.

‘ When you are deal­ing with a much smaller scale — with pae­di­atric pa­tients — you have to be very good tech­ni­cally, but he also has the de­ci­sion­mak­ing skills that de­fine the best doc­tors.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: The Har­ley Street Clinic in Lon­don. ALSO HIGHLY THOUGHT OF . . .


Leeds Gen­eral In­fir­mary


ABOUT HIM: ‘Very sound, sen­si­ble and well­liked by pa­tients,’ says one who nom­i­nated him. ‘NHS treat­ment guide­lines don’t pro­vide you with all of the an­swers and he is some­one who thinks out­side the box, with­out be­ing cav­a­lier.’

‘He’s held in high es­teem, but is quite hum­ble, too,’ says an­other.

PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Nuffield Health Leeds Hos­pi­tal.


St Bartholome­w’s Hos­pi­tal in Lon­don


ABOUT HIM: ‘An excellent doc­tor, ac­tively engaged in re­search — at the fore­front in terms of di­ag­nos­ing and treat­ing in­her­ited ar­rhyth­mia.’ PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: The Har­ley Street Clinic in Lon­don and the Lon­don Heart Cen­tre.


Der­ri­ford Hos­pi­tal in Ply­mouth WHAT THEY SAY

ABOUT HIM: ‘A highly ex­pe­ri­enced car­di­ol­o­gist who is won­der­ful with pa­tients and has de­vel­oped a very im­pres­sive ar­rhyth­mia ser­vice in Ply­mouth,’ says one of his peers. ‘When he set this up maybe 20 years ago, ar­rhyth­mia was seen as a Lon­don do­main and pa­tients would have had to travel up to the cap­i­tal to get treat­ment.

‘What he of­fers in Ply­mouth is as good as could be had in Lon­don — and pa­tients ac­cess it lo­cally.’

PRI­VATE PRAC­TICE: Nuffield Health Ply­mouth Hos­pi­tal.

 ??  ??
 ??  ?? The se­ries that could save your life
The se­ries that could save your life
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from UK