Colin: M&S

Ruth says: “We did a blind taste so Rufus and Cress didn’t know this was the original. But they confirmed Colin is the top caterpillar.”

Cress says: “It was really chocolatey and the sponge was super soft. It wasn’t as sweet as the others which is good ’cos you can eat lots more.” £7, serves 10 SCOFF SCORE: 5/5