Player ratings LIVINGSTON

Robby McCrorie

Made a few good stops and was unlucky with Shaun Rooney’s goal. Livi would have been a lot worse off without him.

Julien Serrano

A threat from set-pieces but was caught out of position occasionally.

Jon Guthrie

Did well to repel St Johnstone’s aerial bombardment. Missed a decent chance at the end of the first half.

Efe Ambrose

Took a sore one in the first half but soldiered on regardless. Good game.

Nicky Devlin

Was a danger with his long throws and did his best to provide width on the right.

Marvin Bartley

Played on the left. Started badly, got worse yet there he stayed until the 70th minute.

Steve Lawson

5 Plenty of industry but far too little guile.

Jason Holt

Largely anonymous. 7

6

6

7

6 4

4

Would have been hoping for that little moment of magic to split the Saints defence but never produced it.

Scott Pittman

Quiet afternoon. Midfield was crying out for someone with his composure on the ball but he could not provide it.

5

Josh Mullin

Tried to make things happen but was not at his best. Good shot in the first half. Hooked for Alan Forrest. 5

Scott Robinson

Full marks for effort but had to do it all himself. Threw himself about and gave everything he had.

6

SUBSTITUTES Craig Sibbald

(for Lawson, 60) Provided greater attacking threat when he came on.

Alan Forrest

(for Mullin, 66) Looked very lively.

Gavin Reilly 3

(for Pittman, 66) Failed to make impact.

Jay Emmanuel-Thomas 3

(for Holt, 71) Failed to make impact.

4 5